Energy Charter Treaty: Towards a New Interpretation in the Light of Paris Agreement and Human Rights
Open Access
- 11 March 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 15 (6) , 5006
Abstract
In addition to climate change, the current war in Ukraine has highlighted the urgency of a rapid transformation to post-fossility. This paper analyses the much-lamented negative climate policy and energy transition impacts of the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) in international law, a treaty that serves as a basis for the compensation claims of fossil fuel companies in response to losses incurred because of climate policy measures. Methodologically, a legal interpretation is conducted, i.e., the ECT is interpreted grammatically and systematically. It is shown that, with a revised legal interpretation of the ECT, such claims usually cannot be upheld at all, except in the case of direct expropriations. This is further underlined by a legal interpretation of the ECT based on the Paris Agreement and on international human rights law. The arbitral ECT tribunals would therefore have to dismiss claims and if they do not do so then, for example, EU member states could take action against such verdicts of the arbitral tribunals before the ECJ. Even if all of this was to be disputed, there are also considerable possibilities for the contracting states to subsequently exclude claims for compensation. Nevertheless, there are a lot of arguments in favour of a comprehensive reform of the treaty. However, to do so as currently planned, with transitional periods, is not sufficient.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Vattenfall vs. Deutschland (II) und das Internationale Investitionsschutzregime in der KritikKj Kritische Justiz, 2014
- International Energy Governance: Weaknesses of MultilateralismInternational Studies Perspectives, 2013
- Climate change and the human rights challenge: extending justice beyond the borders of the nation stateThe International Journal of Human Rights, 2012
- International Energy Governance: The Role of the Energy CharterProceedings of the ASIL Annual Meeting, 2012
- Investment Arbitration and the Energy Charter TreatyJournal of International Dispute Settlement, 2010
- The Increasing Currency and Relevance of Rights-Based Perspectives in the International Negotiations on Climate ChangeJournal of Environmental Law, 2010
- A Core Precautionary Principle*Journal of Political Philosophy, 2006
- The Hungary-Slovakia Danube River dispute: implications for sustainable development and equitable utilization of natural resources in international lawInternational Journal of Global Environmental Issues, 2001
- The European Energy Charter TreatyEnergy Policy, 1996
- Treaties and Changed Circumstances (Rebus Sic Stantibus)American Journal of International Law, 1967