Assessing model sensitivity in ancestral area reconstruction using Lagrange: a case study using the Colchicaceae family
Authors:
- 1 April 2014
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 41 (7) , 1414-1427
Abstract
Aim: Likelihood analyses of ancestral ranges require a parameterized model that consists of a time‐calibrated phylogeny, an ‘adjacency matrix’ of allowed or forbidden area connections, and an ‘area–dispersal’ matrix with probabilities for discrete periods of time. The approach is implemented in the software Lagrange. Because it can incorporate information about past continental positions, the approach has been used in historical biogeographical studies of relatively old clades. Surprisingly, no study has evaluated the interactions among these input matrices. Here we use the lily family Colchicaceae and artificial data to study the relative effect of the input matrices on final estimates.Location: Africa, Australia, Eurasia, North America and South America.Methods: Using eight plastid, mitochondrial and nuclear DNA regions from 85 of the c. 280 species of Colchicaceae (representing all genera and the entire geographical range) and relevant outgroups, we obtained a well‐resolved phylogeny dated with a molecular clock. We then assigned species to six geographical distributions and carried out 22 Lagrange runs in which we modified the adjacency and dispersal matrices, the latter with zero, two or four time periods and one, three or five dispersal probabilities. For a second data set, the areas at deep nodes in the empirical tree were modified by shuffling species distributions. Models were compared based on global log‐likelihoods.Results: The adjacency matrix strongly determined the outcome, while time slices and dispersal probability categories had minor effects. Ancestral areas reconstructed at most nodes were unaffected by the different input matrices. Colchicaceae are likely to have originated in Cretaceous East Gondwana, initially diversified in Australia (c. 67 Ma), reached southern Africa during the Palaeocene–Eocene, and from there extended their range to Southeast Asia (probably through Arabia) and then North America (through Beringia).Main conclusions: At least in small data sets, Lagrange models should be tested with sensitivity analyses as carried out here, concentrating on constrained versus unconstrained adjacency matrices, and it should be good practice to report the set‐up of both input matrices, not just the dispersal matrix, which is the less decisive of the two.Keywords
Funding Information
- Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG RE 603/10-2)
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- MAFFT Multiple Sequence Alignment Software Version 7: Improvements in Performance and UsabilityMolecular Biology and Evolution, 2013
- Distribution of living Cupressaceae reflects the breakup of PangeaProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012
- Temporal and spatial diversification of the African disjunct genus Androcymbium (Colchicaceae)Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 2009
- Maximum Likelihood Inference of Geographic Range Evolution by Dispersal, Local Extinction, and CladogenesisSystematic Biology, 2008
- BEAST: Bayesian evolutionary analysis by sampling treesBMC Ecology and Evolution, 2007
- Correlates of Diversification in the Plant Clade Dipsacales: Geographic Movement and Evolutionary InnovationsThe American Naturalist, 2007
- The genus Colchicum L. redefined to include Androcymbium Willd. based on molecular evidenceTaxon, 2007
- Mitochondrial DNA suggests at least 11 origins of parasitism in angiosperms and reveals genomic chimerism in parasitic plantsBMC Ecology and Evolution, 2007
- Relaxed Phylogenetics and Dating with ConfidencePLOS Biology, 2006
- The Use of Geological and Paleontological Evidence in Evaluating Plant Phylogeographic Hypotheses in the Northern Hemisphere TertiaryInternational Journal of Plant Sciences, 2001