Comparing Cultures and Comparing Processes: Diachronic Methods in Cross-Cultural Anthropology
- 1 November 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Cross-Cultural Research
- Vol. 40 (4) , 377-404
Abstract
If cross-cultural researchers hope to contribute to cultural evolutionary theory, methods must be developed to describe and explain cultural processes. The distinction made by Boas between historical and comparative methods limited scholarly interest in the analysis of patterned historical change. Numerous techniques have been developed to draw diachronic inferences from synchronic ethnographic data, with varying degrees of success. The use of archaeological and historical data to draw diachronic inferences similarly has had mixed results but requires fewer assumptions and allows a more direct comparison of cultural change. Shifting the unit of analysis from the culture to the event allows events to be compared with one another. A case study from the evolution of numerical notation systems shows the potential of rigorous diachronic methodologies to complement synchronic ones. Although synchronic analysis is highly useful for studying correlations between traits, diachronic analysis is far better for analyzing processes of change.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evolutionary Implications of Cross-Cultural CorrelationsCross-Cultural Research, 2003
- City Systems and World Systems: Four Millennia of City Growth and DeclineCross-Cultural Research, 2002
- Horizonal Integration and Regional Diversity: An Alternating Process in the Rise of CivilizationsAmerican Antiquity, 1991
- A Cross‐Cultural Historical Analysis of Subsistence ChangeAmerican Anthropologist, 1990
- Distinguished Lecture: What Kind of Science Is Anthropology?American Anthropologist, 1987
- Entailment Theory and Method: A Cross-Cultural Analysis of the Sexual Division of LaborBehavior Science Research, 1977
- Paradoxes in Western CreativityAmerican Anthropologist, 1972
- Creativity: A Cross-Historical Pilot SurveyJournal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 1971
- Geographical-Historical Versus Psycho-Functional Explanations of Kin AvoidancesCurrent Anthropology, 1966
- Wenner‐Gren Foundation Supper ConferenceAmerican Anthropologist, 1953