Art and Agency : A Reassessment
Author:
- 11 August 2003
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute
- Vol. 9 (3) , 447-464
Abstract
In his book, Art and agency , Alfred Gell presents a theory of art based neither on aesthetics nor on visual communication. Art is defined by the distinctive function it performs in advancing social relationships through ‘the abduction of agency’. Art objects are indexes of the artist's or model's agency. This article examines Gell's use of agency, particularly in relation to the ritual art that is central to his argument. Focusing on Gell's employment of Peirce's term ‘index’ (out of his triad of index, icon, and symbol), I note that Peirce's approach deflects attention from signification towards the link between art works and the things to which they refer. I consider what Peirce meant by abduction, and conclude that while Gell makes a good case for the agency of art objects he does not explain the distinctive ways in which art objects extend their maker's or user's agency. Gell lacked the time to make detailed revisions before publication and I acknowledge that, given more time, he might have revised some parts of the book.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Art and Politics: From Javanese Court Dance to Indonesian ArtJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 1997
- Kiss the Baby Goodbye: "Kowhaiwhai" and Aesthetics in Aotearoa New ZealandCritical Inquiry, 1995
- From Dull to Brilliant: The Aesthetics of Spiritual Power Among the YolnguMan, 1989
- From Head-Dresses to Head-Messages: The Art of Self-Decoration in the Highlands of Papua New GuineaMan, 1988
- Introduction: commodities and the politics of value1986
- The Social Production of Art1981
- The Consecration of a Buddhist ImageThe Journal of Asian Studies, 1966
- Ritual and Social ChangeMan, 1966
- Ritual Man in AfricaAfrica, 1964
- Religion and Ritual: The Definitional ProblemThe British Journal of Sociology, 1961