Computed tomography-based classifications of posterior malleolar fractures and their inter- and intraobserver reliability: a comparison of the Haraguchi, Bartoníček/Rammelt, and Mason classifications
- 30 January 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Archives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery
- Vol. 142 (12) , 3895-3902
Abstract
Introduction Complex ankle fractures often include fractures of the posterior malleolus. The most clinically relevant posterior malleolus fracture classifications are computed tomography (CT) based. These classifications aim to enable clear communication and help develop treatment strategies. This study investigates the inter- and intraobserver reliability of the Haraguchi, Bartoníček/Rammelt and Mason posterior malleolar fracture classifications. Materials and methods CT scans of 113 patients with a mean age of 56.2 (SD ± 17.8) years and fractures involving the posterior malleolus were analyzed twice by 4 observers with different levels of training. The posterior malleolar fractures were classified according to Haraguchi et al., Bartoníček/Rammelt et al. and Mason et al. The intraobserver and interobserver reliabilities were determined by calculating Cohen’s and Fleiss’ kappa values. Results We found substantial multi-rater interobserver agreement for all three classifications. The Haraguchi classification 0.799 (CI 0.744–0.855) showed the highest agreement, followed by the Bartoníček/Rammelt 0.744 (0.695–0.793) and Mason 0.717 (CI 0.666–0.768) classifications. Subgroup analyses showed substantial to perfect agreement for the Haraguchi and substantial agreement for the Bartoníček/Rammelt and Mason classifications independent of observer expertise. The intraobserver reliability was perfect for three and substantial for one of the observers. However, the classifications have certain pitfalls and do not consider the number of fragments, articular surface impressions, or intercalary fragments. Conclusion All classifications show substantial, if not perfect inter- and intraobserver reliabilities independent of observer level of expertise.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Size matters: The influence of the posterior fragment on patient outcomes in trimalleolar ankle fracturesInjury, 2015
- Anatomy and classification of the posterior tibial fragment in ankle fracturesArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2015
- Evaluation of Posterior Malleolar Fractures and the Posterior Pilon Variant in Operatively Treated Ankle FracturesFoot & Ankle International, 2014
- Reliability of Radiologic Assessment of the Fracture Anatomy at the Posterior Tibial Plafond in Malleolar FracturesJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 2009
- Inter-observer reliability and intra-observer reproducibility of the Weber classification of ankle fracturesThe Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume, 2006
- Pathoanatomy of Posterior Malleolar Fractures of the AnkleJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2006
- Plain Radiographic Interpretation in Trimalleolar Ankle Fractures Poorly Assesses Posterior Fragment SizeJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 1994
- Fractures of the Posterior Tibial Margin1989
- Reproducibility of histomorphologic diagnoses with special reference to the kappa statisticAPMIS, 1989
- Epidemiology of ankle fractures in Rochester, MinnesotaActa Orthopaedica, 1987