The Effect of Gender on Awards in Employment Arbitration Cases: The Experience in the Securities Industry
Authors:
- 20 December 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society
- Vol. 52 (s1) , 314-342
Abstract
In this article we analyze the outcomes of nearly 3200 awards issued in employment disputes settled by arbitration in the securities industry over the period 1986–2008. The large amount of litigation in the securities industry alleging discrimination by securities firms against the women they employ led us to hypothesize that women would do less well than men in these arbitration cases. Regression analysis reveals that the gender of the complainant and the complainant's attorney (but not the gender of the respondent's attorney or the arbitrator) had significant effects on the size of the awards. Regardless of the definition of the dependent variable, female complainants did less well than male complainants in these employment arbitration cases. In most estimates, the gender of the attorney representing the complainant also affected the size of the award: male attorneys obtained larger awards than female attorneys. We conclude that these gender differentials are more likely to be the consequence of employment conditions in the securities industry rather than biases in the arbitration process.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Empirical Study of Employment Arbitration: Case Outcomes and ProcessesJournal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2011
- The Ascendancy of Employment Arbitrators in US Employment Relations: A New Actor in the American System?British Journal of Industrial Relations, 2006
- Engendering Inequality: Processes of Sex-Segregation on Wall StreetSociological Forum, 2004
- The Effects of Participants' Ethnicity and Gender on Monetary Outcomes in Mediated and Adjudicated Civil CasesLaw & Society Review, 1996
- Sex effects and sentencing: An analysis of the statistical literatureJustice Quarterly, 1995
- GENDER AND CRIMINAL COURT OUTCOMES: AN HISTORICAL ANALYSIS*Criminology, 1992
- Experimental evidence of gender effects in arbitration decisionsEmployee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 1991
- The effect of gender on arbitration decisionsJournal of Labor Research, 1989
- Gender Effects in Discharge ArbitrationILR Review, 1988
- GENDER EFFECTS IN DISCIPLINE ARBITRATION: EVIDENCE FROM BRITISH COLUMBIA.Academy of Management Journal, 1988