Assessment of (un)sustainability of EU harvest of migratory birds in non‐secure conservation status: Bridging science and policy
Authors:
- Marta Cruz‐FloresMCMarta Cruz‐Flores
- Julien TerraubeJTJulien Terraube
- Beatriz RubioBRBeatriz Rubio
- Matthieu GuillemainMGMatthieu Guillemain
- Jesper MadsenJMJesper Madsen
- Pierre Defos du RauPRPierre Defos du Rau
- Charlotte FrancesiazCFCharlotte Francesiaz
- Carles CarbonerasCCCarles Carboneras
- Beatriz ArroyoBABeatriz Arroyo
Open Access
- 26 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (10)
Abstract
Hunting may affect wildlife, yet there is still limited knowledge (particularly outside North America) about how sustainable hunting can be at the population level. In Europe, out of 84 huntable bird species (after Annex II of the European Union [EU] Birds Directive), 42 are in a non‐secure conservation status. The Birds Directive states that hunting in such cases can only be considered as part of a management plan accompanied by recovery measures. In this context, assessing whether hunting levels are sustainable is critical. We assessed sustainability of current EU hunting levels for 27 bird migratory species in non‐secure conservation status, using Demographic Invariant Models. We used the R package popharvest to calculate a Sustainability Harvest Index (SHI). SHI compares the actual offtake with the Potential Take Level (calculated from demographic parameters and population size), modulated by a factor related to management objectives, F obj . We tested all F obj values between 0 and 1 by 0.01 steps, and present results using a traffic light system: red light was assigned to situations where SHI exceeded 1 in >50% of simulations for F obj Synthesis and applications . Our results allow the identification of the species/populations most likely to be overharvested in the EU, requiring management considerations to ensure compliance with the Birds Directive. Our approach allows us to separate science from policy considerations, facilitating stakeholder discussion and agreement on which species should be prioritized for management. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog .Keywords
Funding Information
- European Commission (09.0201/2022/886665/SER/D.3)
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Unravelling discourses about the management of a migratory declining game species: the case of European Turtle-dove ( Streptopelia turtur )Ecosystems and People, 2024
- Long‐term changes in autumn–winter harvest distributions vary among duck species, months, and subpopulationsEcology and Evolution, 2024
- Using the R package popharvest to assess the sustainability of offtake in birdsEcology and Evolution, 2024
- Understanding and overcoming obstacles in adaptive managementTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2022
- The effect of a ban on the use of lead ammunition for waterfowl hunting on duck and goose crippling rates in IllinoisWildlife Biology, 2022
- Barnacle goose Branta leucopsis derogation shooting effort in relation to abundance and vulnerable cropsAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2022
- popharvest: An R package to assess the sustainability of harvesting regimes of bird populationsEcology and Evolution, 2021
- Temporal variation in survival and recovery rates of lesser scaup: A responseThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2017
- Multilevel Learning in the Adaptive Management of Waterfowl Harvests: 20 Years and CountingWildlife Society Bulletin, 2015
- Key conservation issues for migratory land- and waterbird species on the world's major flywaysBird Conservation International, 2008