The future of UN peace operations: pragmatism, pluralism or statism?
Author:
- Roland ParisRPRoland Paris
Open Access
- 5 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Affairs
- Vol. 100 (5) , 2153-2172
Abstract
Although United Nations peace missions have played an important conflict management role for decades, a backlash against the post-Cold War model of ‘liberal peacebuilding’ and other recent developments have called their future into doubt. Some observers contend that a ‘pragmatic turn’ is now underway—a shift away from ambitious plans to transform war-torn societies into liberal democracies and towards more modest and realistic goals. Whether ‘pragmatism’ offers a viable alternative framework for peacebuilding, however, is less clear. This article challenges key assumptions of the pragmatic approach to peacebuilding, including the notion that UN missions can be ‘agnostic’ about the governance arrangements of societies that host these operations, as some proponents of pragmatism recommend. Historical case-studies show that such assumptions are integral features of collective conflict management systems, including UN peace missions. Moreover, a close examination of the pragmatist approach reveals that it, too, is based on such assumptions—namely, that building peace requires the promotion of pluralist societies and states. Pluralist peacebuilding, the article concludes, could offer a compelling foundation for future UN missions in an era of rising statist–authoritarianism, but developing this approach will first require discarding pragmatism's pretence of ideological agnosticism.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Adaptation or paradigm shift? An interpretation of resilience through the lens of policy changeCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2023
- Preventing violent extremism with resilience, adaptive peacebuilding, and community-embedded approachesCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2023
- The Extraordinary Relationship between Peacekeeping and PeaceBritish Journal of Political Science, 2020
- The Right to Dominate: How Old Ideas About Sovereignty Pose New Challenges for World OrderInternational Organization, 2020
- Protection Through Presence: UN Peacekeeping and the Costs of Targeting CiviliansInternational Organization, 2018
- Navigating Inclusion in Transitions from Conflict: The Formalised Political UnsettlementJournal of International Development, 2017
- Resilience and the ‘everyday’: beyond the paradox of ‘liberal peace’Review of International Studies, 2014
- The concept of interventionReview of International Studies, 2013
- Peacekeeping and the Contagion of Armed ConflictThe Journal of Politics, 2011
- A post-liberal peace: Eirenism and the everydayReview of International Studies, 2009