Children's preference for mixed‐ versus fixed‐ratio schedules of reinforcement: A translational study of risky choice
- 11 January 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior
- Vol. 107 (1) , 161-175
Abstract
Laboratory research has shown that when subjects are given a choice between fixed‐ratio and bi‐valued mixed‐ratio schedules of reinforcement, preference typically emerges for the mixed‐ratio schedule even with a larger ratio requirement. The current study sought to replicate and extend these findings to children's math problem completion. Using an ABCBC reversal design, four fourth‐grade students were given the choice of completing addition problems reinforced on either a fixed‐ratio 5 schedule or one of three mixed‐ratio schedules; an equivalent mixed‐ratio (1, 9) schedule, a mixed‐ratio (1, 11) schedule with a 20% larger ratio requirement, and an equally lean mixed‐ratio (5, 7) schedule without the small fixed‐ratio 1 component. This was followed by a reversal back to the preceding phase in which preference for the mixed‐ratio schedule had been observed, and a final reversal back to the mixed‐ratio (5, 7) phase. Findings were consistent with previous research in that all children preferred the mixed‐ratio (1, 9) schedule over the equivalent fixed‐ratio 5 schedule. Preference persisted for the leaner mixed‐ratio (1, 11) schedule for three of the four children. Indifference or preference for the fixed‐ratio 5 alternative was observed in phases containing the mixed‐ratio (5, 7) schedule. These results extend previous research on risky choice to children's math problem completion and highlight the importance of a small ratio component in the emergence of preference for bi‐valued mixed‐ratio schedules. Implications of these results for arranging reinforcement to increase children's academic responding are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- RISKY CHOICE IN PIGEONS: PREFERENCE FOR AMOUNT VARIABILITY USING A TOKEN‐REINFORCEMENT SYSTEMJournal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 2012
- The role of context in risky choiceBehavioural Processes, 2011
- RISKY CHOICE IN PIGEONS AND HUMANS: A CROSS-SPECIES COMPARISONJournal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 2010
- The Importance of Animal Models of Decision Making, Gambling, and Related Behaviors: Implications for Translational Research in AddictionNeuropsychopharmacology, 2009
- AN EVALUATION OF THE RELATIVE EFFICACY OF AND CHILDREN'S PREFERENCES FOR TEACHING STRATEGIES THAT DIFFER IN AMOUNT OF TEACHER DIRECTEDNESSJournal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 2009
- Risk-sensitive foraging in rats: the effects of response-effort and reward-amount manipulations on choice behaviorBehavioural Processes, 2000
- The effects of explicit timing on mathematics performance in second-grade Caucasian and African American students.School Psychology Quarterly, 1999
- Increasing learning rates by increasing student response rates: A summary of research.School Psychology Quarterly, 1996
- Relative preferences for various bivalued ratio schedulesLearning & Behavior, 1992
- A COMPARISON OF TWO APPROACHES FOR IDENTIFYING REINFORCERS FOR PERSONS WITH SEVERE AND PROFOUND DISABILITIESJournal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1992