Abstract
OBESE PATIENTS and their physicians are often at odds about what constitutes a successful treatment outcome. While there is considerable professional consensus that modest weight losses of 5% to 10% are successful,1-3 obese patients seeking treatment view things quite differently. Studies suggest that the desired weight losses of obese patients are 2 to 3 times greater (a 22%-34% reduction in body weight) than those recommended by professionals as feasible and health promoting.4-6 Moreover, these expectations greatly exceed the average 10% reductions in body weight achieved by the best behavioral and/or pharmacologic treatments.7,8 Population studies have reported similar discrepancies between health provider and lay definitions of desirable weights.9 The discrepancy between desired and actual weight losses can result in unrealistic and negative evaluations of treatment outcomes. For example, obese women seeking treatment characterized a 25% weight loss as "one I would not be happy with" and a 17% weight loss as "one that I could not view as successful in any way."5 Thus, the average 10% weight losses produced by the best available nonsurgical treatments are perceived as even less than unsuccessful.