Predicting species distributions based on incomplete survey data: the trade‐off between precision and scale
Authors:
- Veronika BraunischVBVeronika Braunisch
- Rudi SuchantRSRudi Suchant
Abstract
Systematic species surveys over large areas are mostly not affordable, constraining conservation planners to make best use of incomplete data. Spatially explicit species distribution models (SDM) may be useful to detect and compensate for incomplete information. SDMs can either be based on standardized, systematic sampling in a restricted subarea, or – as a cost‐effective alternative – on data haphazardly collated by “volunteer‐based monitoring schemes” (VMS), area‐wide but inherently biased and of heterogeneous spatial precision. Using data on capercaillie Tetrao urogallus , we evaluated the capacity of SDMs generated from incomplete survey data to localise unknown areas inhabited by the species and to predict relative local observation density. Addressing the trade‐off between data precision, sample size and spatial extent of the sampling area, we compared three different sampling strategies: VMS‐data collected throughout the whole study area (7000 km 2 ) using either 1) exact locations or 2) locations aggregated to grid cells of the size of an average individual home range, and 3) systematic transect counts conducted within a small subarea (23.8 km 2 ). For each strategy, we compared two sample sizes and two modelling methods (ENFA and Maxent), which were evaluated using cross‐validation and independent data. Models based on VMS‐data (strategies 1 and 2) performed equally well in predicting relative observation density and in localizing “unknown” occurrences. They always outperformed strategy 3‐models, irrespective of sample size and modelling method, partly because the VMS‐data provided the more comprehensive clues for setting the discrimination‐threshold for predicting presence or absence. Accounting for potential errors due to extrapolation (e.g. projections outside the environmental domain or potentially biasing variables) reduced, but did not fully compensate for the observed discrepancies. As they cover a broader range of species‐habitat relations, the area‐wide data achieved a better model quality with less a‐priori knowledge. Furthermore, in a highly mobile species like capercaillie a sampling resolution corresponding to an individuals' home range can lead to equally good predictions as the use of exact locations. Consequently, when a trade‐off between the sampling effort and the spatial extent of the sampling area is necessary, less precise data unsystematically collected over a large representative region are preferable to systematically sampled data from a restricted region.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Using ecological forest site mapping for long-term habitat suitability assessments in wildlife conservation—Demonstrated for capercaillie (Tetrao urogallus)Forest Ecology and Management, 2008
- Living on the edge—Modelling habitat suitability for species at the edge of their fundamental nicheEcological Modelling, 2008
- PresenceAbsence: AnRPackage for Presence Absence AnalysisJournal of Statistical Software, 2008
- A Model for Evaluating the ‘Habitat Potential’ of a Landscape for Capercaillie Tetrao urogallus: A Tool for Conservation PlanningWildlife Biology, 2007
- Updating bird species distribution at large spatial scales: applications of habitat modelling to data from long‐term monitoring programsDiversity and Distributions, 2007
- Niche Modeling Perspective on Geographic Range Predictions in the Marine Environment Using a Machine-learning AlgorithmOceanography, 2003
- Evaluating resource selection functionsEcological Modelling, 2002
- Dangers of Using "Optimal" Cutpoints in the Evaluation of Prognostic FactorsJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1994
- Determining Species Response Functions to an Environmental Gradient by Means of a b-FunctionJournal of Vegetation Science, 1994
- DOMAIN: a flexible modelling procedure for mapping potential distributions of plants and animalsBiodiversity and Conservation, 1993