Language Processing Units Are Not Equivalent to Sentences: Evidence from Writing Tasks in Typical and Dyslexic Children
Open Access
Abstract
Despite recent research on the building blocks of language processing, the nature of the units involved in the production of written texts remains elusive: intonation units, which are evidenced by empirical results across a growing body of work, are not suitable for writing, where the sentence remains the common reference. Drawing on the analysis of the writing product and process, our study explores how children with and without dyslexia handle sentences. The children were asked to write a short story and the writing process was recorded using keystroke logging software (Inputlog 7 & 8). We measured the number of pauses, the nature of the language sequences segmented by pauses, and the revision operations performed throughout the process. We analyzed sentences both in product and process. Our results showed that both the written product and the writing process reflect the establishment of a syntactic schema during language processing in typical children, in line with the first functional step in processing. This was not clearly evidenced in the case of dyslexic children, due to their limited production: beyond spelling, syntactic elaboration was also affected. In contrast, it appeared that the units of language processing cannot be equated with sentences in writing: the information flow is produced through usually smaller bursts that each carry part of the meaning or correspond to a specific operation of text crafting and revision.Keywords
Funding Information
- Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR-18-CE23-0024-01, BOF.PDO.2022.0001.01)
- Ghent University (ANR-18-CE23-0024-01, BOF.PDO.2022.0001.01)
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- The process-disruption hypothesis: how spelling and typing skill affects written composition process and productPsychological Research, 2022
- The Relationships Between Oral and Written Sentence Generation in English Speaking Children: The Role of Language and Literacy Skills2016
- Sentence Generation in Children with and Without Problems of Written Expression2016
- Writing in Dyslexia: Product and ProcessDyslexia, 2013
- The Spelling Skills of French‐Speaking Dyslexic ChildrenDyslexia, 2013
- A PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS OF KEYSTROKE LOG DATA FROM A TIMED WRITING TASKETS Research Report Series, 2012
- Child writers’ construction and reconstruction of single sentences and construction of multi-sentence texts: contributions of syntax and transcription to translationReading and Writing, 2010
- Sex Differences in Developmental Reading DisabilityJAMA, 2004
- From language to reading and dyslexia1Dyslexia, 2001
- From sentence production to text production: Investigating fundamental processesEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education, 1991