Market-based carbon pricing mechanisms have emerged as innovative financial mechanisms for reducing carbon emissions, but there is still a lack of comprehensive studies that explore the effects of these mechanisms on carbon emissions from both short/long-term perspectives. The main objective of the study is to fill the gap by analyzing the effectiveness of these mechanisms [carbon taxes (TAX) and Emissions Trading Systems (ETS)] on carbon emissions in the short/long-term. Using data from 31 countries between 2000 and 2023, we conducted a panel ARDL model to estimate the separate and joint effects of these policies on carbon emissions. The findings reveal that TAX and the combination of both instruments are more effective than ETS in reducing emissions in the long-run. However, both policies (alone or concurrently) appear to cause temporary increases in carbon emissions in the short-run, because of implementation costs, structural adjustment costs, market adaptation, and transitional production behaviors, etc. In different lag levels, the findings indicate that the carbon policies decrease per capita carbon emissions gradually and distinctly over time. Overall, the study highlights that carbon tax policies and the combined use of both instruments (ETS and TAX) are effective long-term tools, and these tools offer valuable insights for policymakers.