Beyond Single-Lead ECG-Derived Respiration Analysis: Use of Vectorcardiograms from the EASI-System for Breathing Frequency Estimation—A Feasibility Study
Open Access
Abstract
Precise respiration assessment is crucial for heart rate variability (HRV) interpretation as respiratory components—particularly respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA)—provide essential information on vagally mediated regulation. Conventional single-lead electrocardiogram-derived respiration (EDR) methods measure the amplitude modulation of the QRS-waveform caused by respiratory chest movements. This causes a displacement of the electrical heart axis in relation to the ECG lead axis, typically within the 2D frontal plane of the Einthoven electrode montage. Another approach is based on heartbeat acceleration and deceleration during respective inspiration and expiration causing RR interval modulation. However, interval-based methods depend on the complexity of sympathovagal factors that affect RSA. The present feasibility study accounts for the 3D rotational movement of the electrical heart axis during the respiratory cycle and avoids non-respiratory neuromodulatory confounds. The beat-to-beat cardiac rotation was extracted from Frank-XYZ coordinates reconstructed via a four-electrode EASI device. In a pilot study with data from 19 healthy adults performing acoustically paced breathing (6–18 bpm), three surrogates (, , ) were compared using a unified Python 3.11.13 pipeline (3D VCG R-peak detection, multivariate Mahalanobis artifact correction, wavelet-based analysis) against a synthetic reference derived from the instructed breathing schedule. The results demonstrated a consistently lower estimation error and higher reference-based signal-to-noise ratio (refSNR), measuring spectral alignment with the paced-breathing trajectory for and achieving a mean refSNR of 6.01 dB (vs. 4.62 dB for and 3.20 dB for ) and a mean absolute estimation error of 0.016 Hz (vs. 0.050 Hz and 0.032 Hz, respectively). Notably, and performance slightly improved at higher heart rates, consistent with the interpretation that higher cardiac sampling density benefits spectral resolution for chest movement-based methods, whereas showed no significant heart rate dependence. Furthermore, was compared with the EDR results obtained by applying the Kubios-HRV Premium software (version 3.5.0). Kubios-EDR yielded higher precision at elevated breathing frequencies, whereas outperformed Kubios-EDR at breathing rates below 10 bpm—a range that is particularly relevant for vagally activating slow breathing protocols or treatments. Future work should validate this method using a direct respiration measurement under spontaneous natural breathing conditions.
Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA), vagal tone and biobehavioral integration: Beyond parasympathetic functionBiological Psychology, 2023
- Putting back respiration into respiratory sinus arrhythmia or high-frequency heart rate variability: Implications for interpretation, respiratory rhythmicity, and healthBiological Psychology, 2023
- Reprint of: Mahalanobis, P.C. (1936) "On the Generalised Distance in Statistics."Sankhya A, 2018
- Regression Modeling Strategies2015
- Electrocardiogram Derived Respiratory Rate from QRS Slopes and R-Wave AngleAnnals of Biomedical Engineering, 2014
- Kubios HRV – Heart rate variability analysis softwareComputer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 2014
- Estimation of the respiratory frequency using spatial information in the VCGMedical Engineering & Physics, 2003
- The Mahalanobis distanceChemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 2000
- Deriving the 12-lead electrocardiogram from four (EASI) electrodesJournal of Electrocardiology, 1988
- A lead synthesizer for the Frank system to simulate the standard 12-lead electrocardiogramJournal of Electrocardiology, 1968