Responding to ethical dilemmas in pediatric nephrology: a framework for clinicians in varied practice settings
Authors:
- 18 February 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Pediatric Nephrology
- Vol. 40 (7) , 2145-2160
Abstract
Around the world, pediatric nephrologists encounter challenging clinical situations when decision-making is difficult. Ethical dilemmas occur when the best treatment choice is uncertain or when the nephrologist is constrained from providing a clearly superior treatment option due to conflict or a scarcity of resources. These include decision-making regarding burdensome treatments, disagreements between the nephrologist and parents or other healthcare providers, and inequities in access to therapies. While useful in providing grounding and a starting point, the traditional models of pediatric decision-making are challenged in pediatric nephrology. These limitations can contribute to further conflict and distress. This review will highlight the key ethical principles in ethical dilemmas encountered in clinical pediatric nephrology. We propose a stepwise decision-making framework, consisting of 5 questions, to respond using an ethically defensible process. Using case-based examples, we show how the framework will guide pediatric nephrologists in different practice settings to recognize an ethical dilemma, analyze it systematically, and reach a morally acceptable solution recognizing that this may vary by geographic location, availability of resources, and local cultural practices.Keywords
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Catastrophic healthcare expenditure and caregiver burden in pediatric chronic kidney disease — a mixed methods study from a low resource settingPediatric Nephrology, 2024
- Management dilemmas in pediatric nephrology: moving from friction to flourishing in “challenging” casesPediatric Nephrology, 2024
- Longitudinal associations between socioeconomic position and overall health of children with chronic kidney disease and their carersPediatric Nephrology, 2023
- Shared Decision-Making in PediatricsPediatric Clinics of North America, 2023
- The impact of rural status on pediatric chronic kidney diseasePediatric Nephrology, 2023
- Paediatric nephrology in under-resourced areasPediatric Nephrology, 2021
- Caregiver burden in pediatric dialysisPediatric Nephrology, 2019
- Who Should Ration?AMA Journal of Ethics, 2017
- Deciding for a child: a comprehensive analysis of the best interest standardTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2012
- Parental refusals of medical treatment: the harm principle as threshold for state interventionTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2004