Techniques for identifying cross-disciplinary and ‘hard-to-detect’ evidence for systematic review
- 23 August 2013
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Research Synthesis Methods
- Vol. 5 (1) , 50-59
Abstract
Driven by necessity in our own complex review, we developed alternative systematic ways of identifying relevant evidence where the key concepts are generally not focal to the primary studies' aims and are found across multiple disciplines—that is, hard‐to‐detect evidence. Specifically, we sought to identify evidence on community engagement in public health interventions that aim to reduce health inequalities. Our initial search strategy used text mining to identify synonyms for the concept ‘community engagement’. We conducted a systematic search for reviews on public health interventions, supplemented by searches of trials databases. We then used information in the reviews' evidence tables to gather more information about the included studies than was evident in the primary studies' own titles or abstracts. We identified 319 primary studies cited in reviews after full‐text screening. In this paper, we retrospectively reflect on the challenges and benefits of the approach taken. We estimate that more than a quarter of the studies that were identified would have been missed by typical searching and screening methods. This identification strategy was highly effective and could be useful for reviews of broad research questions, or where the key concepts are unlikely to be the main focus of primary research. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Clarifying differences between review designs and methodsSystematic Reviews, 2012
- Judgment, Resources, and ComplexityEvaluation & the Health Professions, 2012
- Routine development of objectively derived search strategiesSystematic Reviews, 2012
- Applications of text mining within systematic reviewsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2011
- Identifying nurse staffing research in Medline: development and testing of empirically derived search strategies with the PubMed interfaceBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2010
- Searching for systematic reviews of the effects of social and environmental interventions: a case study of children and obesityJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2010
- Supporting Systematic Reviews Using Text MiningSocial Science Computer Review, 2009
- Effectiveness and efficiency of search methods in systematic reviews of complex evidence: audit of primary sourcesBMJ, 2005
- Identifying controlled evaluation studies of road safety interventionsJournal of Safety Research, 2001
- Automatic recognition of multi-word terms:. the C-value/NC-value methodInternational Journal on Digital Libraries, 2000