Error bounds of empirical path loss models at VHF/UHF bands in Kwara State, Nigeria
Authors:
- 1 July 2013
- conference paper
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 602-607
Abstract
Propagation models are used extensively in signal prediction and interference analysis. Peculiarity of these models gives rise to high prediction errors when deployed in a different environment other than the one initially built for. In this paper, we provide the error bounds on the efficacy at predicting path loss for 10 empirical widely used path loss models. The results show that no single model provides a good fit consistently. However, Hata and Davidson models provide good fitness along some selected routes with measured RMSE values of less than 8 dB. ITU-R P.1546-3, Walfisch Ikegami, ECC, Egli, CCIR and FSPL perform woefully, with higher RMSE and SC-RMSE (Spread Corrected RMSE) values. In terms of mean value errors, Hata, Davidson and ITU-R P.5293 models give mean values close to zero. However, COST 231 also provides better skew, while CCIR and ECC gives fair results but ITU-R P. 1546, WI and FSPL give worst results. The prediction errors for Davidson are nearly distributed symmetrically around the mean error of 2.15 dB. It was also observed that, the Gaussian error distribution within the window of ±5 dB dominates the frequency counts. However, the error counts for CCIR model are quite high but spread along the distribution but HATA, FSPL, Walfisch Ikegami and ITU-R P. 5293 models does not follow normal distribution.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Study on Environmental Improvement for DTV White Space Utilization with Narrow Band SystemInternational Journal of Networks and Communications, 2012
- Bounding the Practical Error of Path Loss ModelsInternational Journal of Antennas and Propagation, 2012
- Improving coverage prediction for primary multi-transmitter networks operating in the TV whitespaces2012
- Bounding the error of path loss models2011
- Measurement driven deployment of a two-tier urban mesh access network2006
- Mobile radio propagation path loss studies at VHF/UHF bands in Southern IndiaIEEE Transactions on Broadcasting, 2000
- Comparison of some path loss prediction methods with VHF/UHF measurementsIEEE Transactions on Broadcasting, 1997
- Propagation loss prediction: A comparative study with application to the mobile radio channelIEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, 1985
- Empirical formula for propagation loss in land mobile radio servicesIEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, 1980
- Radio Propagation above 40 MC over Irregular TerrainProceedings of the IRE, 1957