Evaluation of the impact of a third mammographic reading in the French organized breast cancer screening program

Authors:
  • SSSamira Saifi
    Samira Saifi
  • MRMalala Razafija
    Malala Razafija
  • HDHelene Delattre
    Helene Delattre
  • PMPatrick Mensah
    Patrick Mensah
  • ABAgnes Bernoux
    Agnes Bernoux
  • PCPascal Cherel
    Pascal Cherel
  • NSNicolas Sellier
    Nicolas Sellier

Abstract
Background Population-based breast cancer screening program (PBCSP) in France relies on a double reading of mammograms. To limit overdiagnosis and false-positives, a third reading (Read-3) was implemented. This study evaluates its impact in terms of the incidence of interval cancers (Interval-Cancer). Methods The retrospective cohort study includes 1,328,597 mammograms (MT0) classified as negative in Reading-1 and reviewed in Reading-2. These MT0 were performed between 2001 and 2022 on 426,603 women aged 50-74 years, residing in Seine-Saint-Denis and Val-d’Oise, France. Two groups were compared: i)- Mammo-Index classified as negative in Read-2 (Control-Group, 1,312,341 MT0); ii)- Mammograms-Index initially positive in Read-2 but reclassified as negative in Read-3 (Experimental-Group, 16,256 MT0). Two hierarchical models explored the determinants of positivity in Read-2 and Read-3. The incidence of cancers, particularly Interval-Cancer (≤23 months after Mammograms-Index), were compared using an adjusted Cox proportional Hazard-ratio model. Results Confirmation of positivity by Read-3 was more likely when the radiological abnormality (Architectural-distortion, Focal-asymmetry, Microcalcifications, Round-mass, Spiculated-mass) was seen in Read-3, regardless of the assessment made in Read-2. The risk of Interval-Cancer was higher in the Experimental-Group (Hazard-ratio=2.1 [1.4–3.2], p=0.009). However, no increased risk was observed beyond 24 months (Hazard-ratio=0.9 [0.7–1.2], p =0.52). Read-3 avoided more than 6,000 ultrasounds, 700 biopsies, and nearly 7,600 additional mammograms. Conclusion While it reduces the overuse of exams, Read-3 increases the Interval-Cancer risk. These results underline the interest of a national reflection on the place of a targeted Read-3 with a security reference framework, or even its replacement by AI-based decision-making tools.