‘The Days of Brilliancy are Past’: Skill, Styles and the Changing Rules of Surgical Performance, ca. 1820–1920
Open Access
- 19 June 2015
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Medical History
- Vol. 59 (3) , 379-403
Abstract
This paper examines how, over the course of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the appreciation of skill in surgery shifted in characteristic ways. Skill is a problematic category in surgery. Its evaluation is embedded into wider cultural expectations and evaluations, which changed over time. The paper examines the discussions about surgical skill in a variety of contexts: the highly competitive environment of celebrity practitioners in the amphitheatres of early nineteenth-century Britain; the science-oriented, technocratic German-language university hospitals later in the century; and the elitist surgeons of late nineteenth and early twentieth-century United States with their concerns about distancing themselves from commercialism and cheap showmanship. For analysing the interaction of surgical practices with their various contexts the paper makes use of the concept of ‘performance’ and examines how the rules of surgical performance varied according to the prevailing technical, social, and moral conditions. Over the course of the century, surgical performance looked more and more recognisably modern, increasingly following the ideals of replicability, universality and standardisation. The changing ideals of surgical skill are a crucial element of the complex history of the emergence of modern surgery, but also an illuminating example of the history of skill in modern medicine.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risk, Responsibility and Surgery in the 1890s and Early 1900sMedical History, 2013
- Asepsis and Bacteriology: A Realignment of Surgery and Laboratory Science1Medical History, 2012
- How Science Became TechnicalIsis, 2009
- Surgery in the Pre-Anaesthetic Era: The Life and Work of Robert ListonHealth and History, 2000
- William Halsted and Theodor KocherAnnals of Surgery, 1978
- THE CONTROL OF BLEEDING IN OPERATIONS FOR BRAIN TUMORS. WITH THE DESCRIPTION OF SILVER “CLIPS” FOR THE OCCLUSION OF VESSELS INACCESSIBLE TO THE LIGATUREAnnals of Surgery, 1911
- ASEPTIC SURGICAL TECHNIQUEAnnals of Surgery, 1904
- Ueber Versuche, die „aseptische” Wundbehandlung zu einer wirklich keimfreien Methode zu vervollkommnenDMW - Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift, 1897
- A MANUAL OF OPERATIVE SURGERYThe American Journal of the Medical Sciences, 1892
- THE LANCET.: LONDON: SATURDAY, OCTOBER 16, 1875The Lancet, 1875