Data quality biases normative models derived from fetal brain MRI
Authors:
- Thomas SanchezTSThomas Sanchez
- Angeline MihailovAMAngeline Mihailov
- Gerard Martí-JuanGMGerard Martí-Juan
- Nadine GirardNGNadine Girard
- Mathieu MilhMMMathieu Milh
- Elisenda EixarchEEElisenda Eixarch
- Vincent DunetVincent Dunet
- Mériam KoobMériam Koob
- Léo PomarLPLéo Pomar
- Joanna SichitiuJSJoanna Sichitiu
- Miguel Ángel González BallesterMBMiguel Ángel González Ballester
Preprint
Abstract
Normative modeling is increasingly used to characterize typical growth trajectories and identify atypical neurodevelopment, including early brain development using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) acquired before birth. Recent work has emphasized the importance of large sample sizes for accurate and robust centile estimation. In this study, we investigate how image quality influences fetal brain normative models, a critical factor in this context where MRI is acquired on a moving fetus in utero. Using a multi-centric cohort of 635 fetal MRI scans, we applied a standardized visual quality control (QC) protocol with continuous quality ratings. We fit normative models for multiple brain structures under progressively relaxed QC stringency, and quantified the deviations in centile estimates relative to a high-quality reference subgroup. Our results showed that including lower-quality data systematically biased normative centiles, with the strongest effects observed in the outer centiles, particularly the lower tail (1st-10th). Bias increased progressively as QC stringency was relaxed and could not be attributed solely to the number of subjects used to fit the models. Quality-induced bias was structure-dependent, and often not visually apparent at the segmentation level. These findings highlight that image quality is an important source of bias in normative fetal brain modeling, and that increasing sample size at the expense of quality may systematically affect centile estimates, potentially jeopardizing the utility of the model.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- The promise of quantifying individual risk for brain disorders through normative modeling, a narrative reviewNeuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 2025
- Whole Brain MRI Assessment of Age and Sex‐Related R2* Changes in the Human Fetal BrainHuman Brain Mapping, 2025
- Assessing Data Quality on Fetal Brain MRI Reconstruction: A Multi-site and Multi-rater Study2024
- Site effects in multisite fetal brain MRI: morphological insights into early brain developmentEuropean Radiology, 2024
- Automated 3D reconstruction of the fetal thorax in the standard atlas space from motion-corrupted MRI stacks for 21–36 weeks GA rangeMedical Image Analysis, 2022
- Normative biometry of the fetal brain using magnetic resonance imagingBrain Structure and Function, 2016
- Understanding Heterogeneity in Clinical Cohorts Using Normative Models: Beyond Case-Control StudiesBiological Psychiatry, 2016
- Head motion during MRI acquisition reduces gray matter volume and thickness estimatesNeuroImage, 2015
- Reconstruction of fetal brain MRI with intensity matching and complete outlier removalMedical Image Analysis, 2012
- MRI denoising using Non-Local MeansMedical Image Analysis, 2008