Experimental design for estimating parameters of rate‐limited mass transfer: Analysis of stream tracer studies
Authors:
- Brian J. WagnerBWBrian J. Wagner
- Judson W. HarveyJHJudson W. Harvey
- 1 July 1997
- journal article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 33 (7) , 1731-1741
Abstract
Tracer experiments are valuable tools for analyzing the transport characteristics of streams and their interactions with shallow groundwater. The focus of this work is the design of tracer studies in high‐gradient stream systems subject to advection, dispersion, groundwater inflow, and exchange between the active channel and zones in surface or subsurface water where flow is stagnant or slow moving. We present a methodology for (1) evaluating and comparing alternative stream tracer experiment designs and (2) identifying those combinations of stream transport properties that pose limitations to parameter estimation and therefore a challenge to tracer test design. The methodology uses the concept of global parameter uncertainty analysis, which couples solute transport simulation with parameter uncertainty analysis in a Monte Carlo framework. Two general conclusions resulted from this work. First, the solute injection and sampling strategy has an important effect on the reliability of transport parameter estimates. We found that constant injection with sampling through concentration rise, plateau, and fall provided considerably more reliable parameter estimates than a pulse injection across the spectrum of transport scenarios likely encountered in high‐gradient streams. Second, for a given tracer test design, the uncertainties in mass transfer and storage‐zone parameter estimates are strongly dependent on the experimental Damkohler number, DaI, which is a dimensionless combination of the rates of exchange between the stream and storage zones, the stream‐water velocity, and the stream reach length of the experiment. Parameter uncertainties are lowest at DaI values on the order of 1.0. When DaI values are much less than 1.0 (owing to high velocity, long exchange timescale, and/or short reach length), parameter uncertainties are high because only a small amount of tracer interacts with storage zones in the reach. For the opposite conditions (DaI ≫ 1.0), solute exchange rates are fast relative to stream‐water velocity and all solute is exchanged with the storage zone over the experimental reach. As DaI increases, tracer dispersion caused by hyporheic exchange eventually reaches an equilibrium condition and storage‐zone exchange parameters become essentially nonidentifiable.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating the Reliability of the Stream Tracer Approach to Characterize Stream‐Subsurface Water ExchangeWater Resources Research, 1996
- Parent lithology, surface–groundwater exchange, and nitrate retention in headwater streamsLimnology and Oceanography, 1996
- Reactive Solute Transport in Streams: 2. Simulation of a pH Modification ExperimentWater Resources Research, 1996
- Transient Storage in Appalachian and Cascade Mountain Streams as Related to Hydraulic CharacteristicsJournal of the North American Benthological Society, 1993
- An efficient numerical solution of the transient storage equations for solute transport in small streamsWater Resources Research, 1993
- Optimal Configuration and Scheduling of Ground‐Water Tracer TestJournal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 1991
- Sampling Network Design for Transport Parameter IdentificationJournal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 1990
- Concepts and Methods for Assessing Solute Dynamics in Stream EcosystemsJournal of the North American Benthological Society, 1990
- EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OF THE AGGREGATED DEAD ZONE MODEL.Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 1989
- Simulation of solute transport in a mountain pool‐and‐riffle stream: A transient storage modelWater Resources Research, 1983