Which Comes First the Simulation or the Lecture?
Authors:
- 1 November 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Educational Computing Research
- Vol. 7 (4) , 469-481
Abstract
Research into the instructional effectiveness of computer-based simulations has yielded inconsistent results. Part of this inconsistency can be attributed to the inappropriate instructional roles for which simulations are used. Two of the most promising roles of simulations in instruction are to: 1) establish a cognitive framework or structure to accommodate further learning in a related subject area, and 2) provide an opportunity for reinforcing, integrating and extending previously learned material. Thus, the effectiveness of a given simulation may depend upon when it is administered within an instructional sequence. The purpose of these two studies was to: 1) ascertain the value of a particular simulation to the learning of genetics principles, and 2) determine whether the position of the simulation, within the sequence of instructional events, altered its effectiveness. In both studies, students receiving the stimulation as a framework for understanding prior to formal classroom instruction scored significantly higher on an applications posttest than did students using the simulation as an integrating activity following formal instruction. Both groups scored higher than a control group which did not use the simulation prior to the posttest.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Models for UnderstandingReview of Educational Research, 1989
- Where are we?Simulation & Games, 1988
- The Educational Effectiveness of Simulation GamesSimulation & Games, 1981
- The Integration of Research Studies on the Use of Simulation as an Instructional StrategyThe Journal of Educational Research, 1981
- The Psychology of How Novices Learn Computer ProgrammingACM Computing Surveys, 1981
- Some Theoretical Considerations in the Evaluation of Instructional Simulation GamesSimulation & Games, 1977
- Comparative Simulation Game ResearchSimulation & Games, 1977
- Prior knowledge or advance organizers as effective variables in chemical learningJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1976
- Advance Organizers in Learning Abstract MathematicsAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1967
- Some Current Research On Effectiveness of Educational Simulations: Implications for Alternative StrategiesAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 1966