A comparison of clinical protocols for assessing postoperative fecal continence in anorectal malformation
- 19 October 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Pediatric Surgery International
- Vol. 28 (1) , 1-4
Abstract
We compared four protocols for assessing fecal continence (FC) in anorectal malformation (ARM). Of 111 ARM cases we treated by anoplasty from 1995 to 2007, 59 have been followed up for more than 4 years [male high (n = 23), male low (n = 12), female high (n = 7), and female low (n = 17)] and 27 for more than 7 years [male high (n = 11), male low (n = 5), female high (n = 5), and female low (n = 6)]. FC was assessed in these 86 cases using each of the four protocols; the Kelly score (0–6 points), the Japanese Study Group of Anorectal Anomalies (JSGA) score (0–8 points), the Holschneider score (0–14 points), and our original score (0–10 points). Results were re-classified into four outcome levels (good, fair, poor, very poor) for direct comparison. Outcome was different by two levels (i.e., good vs. very poor) in 7 (8.1%) assessments and different by one category (i.e., fair vs. poor) in ten assessments (11.6%). Outcome was different most often in male high ARM cases and JSGA scores were most divergent. Fecal continence in male high ARM appears to be assessed inconsistently and a review of protocols may be of value to standardize clinical assessment and enhance reliability.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Midterm postoperative clinicoradiologic analysis of surgery for high/intermediate-type imperforate anus: prospective comparative study between laparoscopy-assisted and posterior sagittal anorectoplastyJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2008
- Preliminary report on the International Conference for the Development of Standards for the Treatment of Anorectal MalformationsJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2005
- Long-term outcome after internal sphincter myectomy for internal sphincter achalasiaPediatric Surgery International, 2004
- Surgical Methods for Anorectal Malformations from Rehbein to Peña - Critical Assessment of Score Systems and Proposal for a New ClassificationEuropean Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 2002
- Posterior sagittal anorectoplasty is superior to sacroperineal-sacroabdominoperineal pull-through: A long-term follow-up study in boys with high anorectal anomaliesJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 1999
- The Clinical and Radiological Assessment of Anal Continence in ChildhoodAnz Journal of Surgery, 1972
- Some comments on the surgical treatment of imperforate anusThe American Journal of Surgery, 1960