Secure rights and non-credibility: the paradoxical dynamics of canal irrigation in India
- 5 October 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Peasant Studies
- Vol. 43 (6) , 1310-1331
Abstract
This paper contributes to the collection on institutional form versus function by looking at the opposite side of the conceptual equation: clear and formal property rights coupled to low credibility. Since colonial times the formal property rights of the means of agricultural production are clear in South Asian large-scale canal irrigation. However, legal entitlements to water are routinely violated, while canal irrigation exhibits a series of ‘performance problems’. Legally clearly and securely defined entitlements to water co-exist with unequal distribution in the Tungabhadra Left Bank Canal irrigation system in south India. Neither the formal institutions nor their insecurity or lack of clarity can explain the existing dynamics and functions of canal irrigation. This lack of analytical purchase derives both from the limitations of property-focused theory and from the inherent characteristics of canal irrigation. Critiques of reductionist approaches have provided a richer conceptual vocabulary, which emphasises the plurality of rights/entitlements as well as that of the causalities at work. Such critiques and the elaboration of alternative frameworks for analysis remain relevant as discourses and practices of ‘marketisation’ of water may be gaining relevance for canal irrigation (reform) in India.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- In defense of endogenous, spontaneously ordered development: institutional functionalism and Chinese property rightsThe Journal of Peasant Studies, 2013
- The Material Conditions of a Polarized Discourse: Clamours and Silences in Critical Analysis of Agricultural Water Use in IndiaJournal of Agrarian Change, 2010
- Water Law, Poverty, and Development2009
- Water pricing in irrigation: the lifetime of an idea.2007
- The Limitations of Water Regulation: The Failure of the Cochabamba Concession in BoliviaBulletin of Latin American Research, 2002
- Bringing water markets down to earth: The political economy of water rights in Chile, 1976–1995World Development, 1997
- Modules for modernisation: Colonial irrigation in India and the technological dimension of agrarian changeThe Journal of Development Studies, 1995
- The fruits and fallacies of neoliberalism: The case of irrigation policyWorld Development, 1989
- Enhancing Production Through Crop Pattern ChangesArtha Vijnana: Journal of The Gokhale Institute of Politics and Economics, 1989
- Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of EmbeddednessAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1985