Doctoral Preparation in Mathematics Education: Graduates’ Perspectives on Program Features, Expertise Development, and Scholarly Learning Cultures
Open Access
- 24 June 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
- Vol. 24 (6) , 69
Abstract
This study examined doctoral preparation in mathematics education through graduates’ retrospective perspectives on program features, expertise development, and scholarly learning cultures. Using a convergent mixed-methods design, survey responses from 156 doctoral graduates representing 37 countries were integrated with in-depth interviews from 16 participants across ten national contexts. Quantitative analyses examined graduates’ ratings of 13 program features and their perceptions of when research, mathematics content, teaching, and professional expertise should develop: before doctoral study, during doctoral study, or through postdoctoral professional practice. Qualitative reflexive thematic analysis explored participants’ accounts of supervision, research participation, scholarly writing, conference engagement, international collaboration, and researcher identity development. Findings indicate that graduates consistently rated theoretical grounding, engagement with mathematics education research literature, and deep understanding of mathematical ideas as especially important. Research expertise was most often perceived as developing during doctoral study, whereas several teaching, supervisory, leadership, and professional responsibilities were described as developing more fully after graduation. Interview findings highlight the central role of supervisory relationships, research communities, scholarly writing, and professional networks in shaping doctoral learning. Rather than treating graduates’ perspectives as direct prescriptions for program design, the study interprets them as situated, retrospective accounts of how doctoral preparation is experienced across diverse institutional and national contexts. Together, the findings provide an empirically grounded account of doctoral preparation in mathematics education as scholarly formation within structured learning cultures.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Supervisors’ competences from doctoral students’ perspectives – a systematic reviewEducational Review, 2024
- Relationship between doctoral supervisors’ competencies, engagement in supervisory development and experienced support from research communityInnovations in Education and Teaching International, 2022
- What perspectives underlie ‘researcher identity’? A review of two decades of empirical studiesHigher Education, 2020
- Examining the career paths of doctorates in mathematics education working in institutions of higher educationInvestigations in Mathematics Learning, 2018
- A profile of mathematics education doctoral graduates’ background and preparation in the United StatesInvestigations in Mathematics Learning, 2017
- Employing Agency in Academic Settings: Doctoral Students Shaping Their Own Experiences2014
- Identity and agency: pleasures and collegiality among the challenges of the doctoral journeyStudies in Continuing Education, 2009
- Communities of Practice1998
- The training of researchers in mathematics education ? Results from an international surveyEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1994
- Situated Learning1991