The Case Anatomical Knowledge Index (CAKI): A novel method used to assess anatomy content in clinical cases
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Anatomical Sciences Education
- Vol. 2 (1) , 9-18
Abstract
There are concerns in the literature that the use of case‐based teaching of anatomy could be compromising the depth and scope of anatomy learned by students in a problem‐based learning curriculum. Poor selection of clinical cases that are used as vehicles for teaching/learning anatomy may be the root problem because some clinical cases do not provide enough opportunities to learn anatomy and are, therefore, inappropriate for case‐based teaching. Although anatomy educators are expected to respond to the identified deficiencies of case‐based anatomy teaching, making sure that students acquire sufficient anatomical knowledge to practice safely and successfully, there are no tools available that can help improve the selection of clinical cases for case‐based teaching. The author proposes a composite index, which incorporates considerations of anatomical knowledge for evaluating clinical cases/conditions for suitability in case‐based anatomy teaching. The development of the case anatomical knowledge index (CAKI) using a modified Guttman procedure is described. The scalability of the index was measured using the coefficient of reproducibility. A total of 47 clinicians participated in the validation activities that measured interrater and intraclass reliability. The CAKI was able to consistently discriminate between clinical cases/conditions with higher demand for anatomical knowledge than those with lower demand for anatomical knowledge. A review of the literature suggests that such an index has not been previously reported. Given the concerns about the depth and scope of anatomy learning in case‐based teaching, these findings have international relevance. Anat Sci Ed 2:9–18, 2009. © 2009 American Association of Anatomists.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- How much anatomy is enough?Anatomical Sciences Education, 2008
- Do students have sufficient knowledge of clinical anatomy?Medical Education, 2005
- Evaluation of the Clinical Anatomy Program in the Medical School of Porto by two cohorts of studentsClinical Anatomy, 2002
- Clinimetrics and Psychometrics Work Hand in HandArchives of internal medicine (1960), 1999
- Adequacy of medical school gross anatomy education as perceived by certain postgraduate residency programs and anatomy course directorsClinical Anatomy, 1999
- Introducing a problem-based anatomy course in a traditional curriculum: a Croatian experienceMedical Teacher, 1998
- Studentsʼ use of anatomy modules in problem-based medical education at McMaster UniversityAcademic Medicine, 1996
- The use of small group case‐based exercises in human gross anatomy: A method for introducing active learning in a traditional course formatClinical Anatomy, 1994
- Self‐directed learning in anatomy: incorporation of case‐based studies into a conventional medical curriculumMedical Education, 1990
- Integration of clinical problems in teaching gross anatomy: Living anatomy, X‐ray anatomy, patient presentations, and films depicting clinical problemsThe Anatomical Record, 1986