Controversies in defining and determining death in critical care
Open Access
- 19 February 2013
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Neurology
- Vol. 9 (3) , 164-173
Abstract
Since the development of life support technology, the precise definition of death has been challenging. James Bernat outlines the brain criteria and the circulatory–respiratory criteria of death, and discusses controversial issues surrounding these definitions, such as a lack of standardization in the field. Ethical challenges in the context of organ donation are also considered. Circulatory–respiratory or brain tests are widely accepted for definition and determination of death, but have several controversial issues. Both determinations have been stimulated by organ donation, but must be valid independently of this process. Current controversies in brain death include whether the definition is conceptually coherent, whether the whole-brain or brainstem criterion is correct, whether one neurological examination or two should be required, and when to conduct the examination following therapeutic hypothermia. Controversies about the circulatory determination of death include the minimum duration of asystole that is sufficient for death to be declared, and whether the distinction between permanent and irreversible cessation of circulatory functioning is important. In addition, the goal of organ donation raises issues such as the optimal way to time and conduct the request conversation with family members of the patient, and whether the Dead Donor Rule should be abandoned.Keywords
This publication has 113 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic Review of Attitudes Toward Donation After Cardiac Death Among Healthcare Providers and the General Public*Critical Care Medicine, 2013
- A systematic review of autoresuscitation after cardiac arrest*Critical Care Medicine, 2010
- Organ donation, patients’ rights, and medical responsibilities at the end of life*Critical Care Medicine, 2009
- How can we achieve uniformity in brain death determinations?Neurology, 2008
- National evaluation of healthcare provider attitudes toward organ donation after cardiac death*Critical Care Medicine, 2006
- Brain Death and the Historical Understanding of BioethicsJournal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 2003
- The Ethics of Elective (Non‐Therapeutic) VentilationBioethics, 2000
- BRAIN DEATHNeurologic Clinics, 1999
- Contesting the natural in Japan: Moral dilemmas and technologies of dyingCulture, Medicine, and Psychiatry, 1995
- Lateral Displacement of the Brain and Level of Consciousness in Patients with an Acute Hemispheral MassNew England Journal of Medicine, 1986