Is Implicit Motor Learning Preserved after Stroke? A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis
Open Access
- 16 December 2016
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 11 (12) , e0166376
Abstract
Many stroke patients experience difficulty with performing dual-tasks. A promising intervention to target this issue is implicit motor learning, as it should enhance patients’ automaticity of movement. Yet, although it is often thought that implicit motor learning is preserved post-stroke, evidence for this claim has not been systematically analysed yet. Therefore, we systematically reviewed whether implicit motor learning is preserved post-stroke, and whether patients benefit more from implicit than from explicit motor learning. We comprehensively searched conventional (MEDLINE, Cochrane, Embase, PEDro, PsycINFO) and grey literature databases (BIOSIS, Web of Science, OpenGrey, British Library, trial registries) for relevant reports. Two independent reviewers screened reports, extracted data, and performed a risk of bias assessment. Overall, we included 20 out of the 2177 identified reports that allow for a succinct evaluation of implicit motor learning. Of these, only 1 study investigated learning on a relatively complex, whole-body (balance board) task. All 19 other studies concerned variants of the serial-reaction time paradigm, with most of these focusing on learning with the unaffected hand (N = 13) rather than the affected hand or both hands (both: N = 4). Four of the 20 studies compared explicit and implicit motor learning post-stroke. Meta-analyses suggest that patients with stroke can learn implicitly with their unaffected side (mean difference (MD) = 69 ms, 95% CI[45.1, 92.9], p < .00001), but not with their affected side (standardized MD = -.11, 95% CI[-.45, .25], p = .56). Finally, implicit motor learning seemed equally effective as explicit motor learning post-stroke (SMD = -.54, 95% CI[-1.37, .29], p = .20). However, overall, the high risk of bias, small samples, and limited clinical relevance of most studies make it impossible to draw reliable conclusions regarding the effect of implicit motor learning strategies post-stroke. High quality studies with larger samples are warranted to test implicit motor learning in clinically relevant contexts.Keywords
This publication has 82 references indexed in Scilit:
- Repeated Split-Belt Treadmill Training Improves Poststroke Step Length AsymmetryNeurorehabilitation and Neural Repair, 2013
- Motor skill depends on knowledge of factsFrontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2013
- Neural correlates of skill acquisition: Decreased cortical activity during a serial interception sequence learning taskNeuroImage, 2011
- Implicit sequence‐specific motor learning after subcortical stroke is associated with increased prefrontal brain activations: An fMRI StudyHuman Brain Mapping, 2011
- Probing the allocation of attention in implicit (motor) learningJournal of Sports Sciences, 2010
- Interactions between cognitive tasks and gait after stroke: A dual task studyGait & Posture, 2008
- Benefits of an external focus of attention: Common coding or conscious processing?Journal of Sports Sciences, 2006
- Analogy learning: A means to implicit motor learningJournal of Sports Sciences, 2001
- From novice to no know-how: A longitudinal study of implicit motor learningJournal of Sports Sciences, 2000
- Functional Mapping of Sequence Learning in Normal HumansJournal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 1995