What gives rise to clinician gut feeling, its influence on management decisions and its prognostic value for children with RTI in primary care: a prospective cohort study
Authors:
- Sophie TurnbullSTSophie Turnbull
- Patricia J. LucasPLPatricia J. Lucas
- Niamh M. RedmondNRNiamh M. Redmond
- Hannah ChristensenHCHannah Christensen
- Hannah ThorntonHTHannah Thornton
- Christie CabralCCChristie Cabral
- Peter S. BlairPBPeter S. Blair
- Brendan C. DelaneyBDBrendan C. Delaney
- Matthew ThompsonMTMatthew Thompson
- Paul LittlePaul Little
- Tim J. PetersTPTim J. Peters
- Alastair D. HayAlastair D. Hay
Open Access
- 5 February 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Family Practice
- Vol. 19 (1) , 25
Abstract
The objectives were to identify 1) the clinician and child characteristics associated with; 2) clinical management decisions following from, and; 3) the prognostic value of; a clinician’s ‘gut feeling something is wrong’ for children presenting to primary care with acute cough and respiratory tract infection (RTI). Multicentre prospective cohort study where 518 primary care clinicians across 244 general practices in England assessed 8394 children aged ≥3 months and < 16 years for acute cough and RTI. The main outcome measures were: Self-reported clinician ‘gut feeling’; clinician management decisions (antibiotic prescribing, referral for acute admission); and child’s prognosis (reconsultation with evidence of illness deterioration, hospital admission in the 30 days following recruitment). Clinician years since qualification, parent reported symptoms (illness severity score ≥ 7/10, severe fever < 24 h, low energy, shortness of breath) and clinical examination findings (crackles/ crepitations on chest auscultation, recession, pallor, bronchial breathing, wheeze, temperature ≥ 37.8 °C, tachypnoea and inflamed pharynx) independently contributed towards a clinician ‘gut feeling that something was wrong’. ‘Gut feeling’ was independently associated with increased antibiotic prescribing and referral for secondary care assessment. After adjustment for other associated factors, gut feeling was not associated with reconsultations or hospital admissions. Clinicians were more likely to report a gut feeling something is wrong, when they were more experienced or when children were more unwell. Gut feeling is independently and strongly associated with antibiotic prescribing and referral to secondary care, but not with two indicators of poor child health.Keywords
Funding Information
- Programme Grants for Applied Research (RP-PG-0608-10018)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- The TARGET cohort study protocol: a prospective primary care cohort study to derive and validate a clinical prediction rule to improve the targeting of antibiotics in children with respiratory tract illnessesBMC Health Services Research, 2013
- The Cognitive Reflection Test as a predictor of performance on heuristics-and-biases tasksMemory & Cognition, 2011
- Gut Feelings as a Third Track in General Practitioners’ Diagnostic ReasoningJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2010
- Effect of antibiotic prescribing in primary care on antimicrobial resistance in individual patients: systematic review and meta-analysisBMJ, 2010
- Diagnostic value of clinical features at presentation to identify serious infection in children in developed countries: a systematic reviewThe Lancet, 2010
- Multiple imputation for missing data in epidemiological and clinical research: potential and pitfallsBMJ, 2009
- The diagnostic role of gut feelings in general practice A focus group study of the concept and its determinantsBMC Family Practice, 2009
- Strengthening the reporting of observational studies in epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studiesBMJ, 2007
- Advanced paediatric life support, 3rd edn: Advanced Life Support Group. (pound25). BMJ Books, 2001. ISBN 0-7279-1554-1Emergency Medicine Journal, 2002
- Capillary refill and core-peripheral temperature gap as indicators of haemodynamic status in paediatric intensive care patientsArchives of Disease in Childhood, 1999