AI Entanglement: Accounting for dependencies in general-purpose AI policy, regulation, and practice

Authors:

Abstract
AI artifacts like models, datasets, and web platforms increasingly help build other AI artifacts. Developers rely on existing models to generate training datasets, incorporate existing datasets to create benchmarks for model evaluation, and access AI-based web platforms to collect additional user data. Altogether these practices create chains of influence in general-purpose AI systems that may be indirect, dynamic, distributed across organizations, or absent from conventional documentation. We call this condition AI entanglement. This Article defines AI entanglement and distinguishes it as a particular manifestation of the broader AI supply chain ecosystem. Concentrating on the consequences of model-specific dependencies, we present a taxonomy of ten recurring model dependency mechanisms across the general-purpose AI development lifecycle. Drawing on technical reports, public disclosures, industry practices, and empirical studies, we show how upstream models can transmit or amplify errors, bias, privacy risks, security vulnerabilities, and behavioral tendencies in downstream systems, often in ways that traditional evaluations of the final model alone may not reveal. AI entanglement also exposes a mismatch between contemporary AI development and the assumptions embedded in governance and law. Existing governance frameworks often presume a discernible system, identifiable actors, and components whose roles can be traced. But an upstream artifact may materially shape a downstream system without remaining part of the deployed product; relevant knowledge, control, and remedial capacity may be divided among multiple actors; and changes to one dependency may affect many downstream systems at once. These dynamics complicate transparency, risk assessment, auditing, incident response, and the allocation of responsibility. They also create challenges for emerging AI regulation and for the application of existing law. By making these relationships visible, a framework of AI entanglement reorients AI governance from isolated general-purpose AI systems toward the networks of dependencies through which risks, decisions, and responsibility travel.