How well do selection tools predict performance later in a medical programme?
- 3 September 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 17 (5) , 615-626
Abstract
The choice of tools with which to select medical students is complex and controversial. This study aimed to identify the extent to which scores on each of three admission tools (Admission GPA, UMAT and structured interview) predicted the outcomes of the first major clinical year (Y4) of a 6 year medical programme. Data from three student cohorts (n = 324) were analysed using regression analyses. The Admission GPA was the best predictor of academic achievement in years 2 and 3 with regression coefficients (B) of 1.31 and 0.9 respectively (each P < 0.001). Furthermore, Admission GPA predicted whether or not a student was likely to earn ‘Distinction’ rather than ‘Pass’ in year 4. In comparison, UMAT and interview showed low predictive ability for any outcomes. Interview scores correlated negatively with those on the other tools. None of the tools predicted failure to complete year 4 on time, but only 3% of students fell into this category. Prior academic achievement remains the best measure of subsequent student achievement within a medical programme. Interview scores have little predictive value. Future directions include longer term studies of what UMAT predicts, and of novel ways to combine selection tools to achieve the optimum student cohort.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Admission selection criteria as predictors of outcomes in an undergraduate medical course: A prospective studyMedical Teacher, 2011
- Has the UK Clinical Aptitude Test improved medical student selection?Medical Education, 2010
- Comparison of A level and UKCAT performance in students applying to UK medical and dental schools in 2006: cohort studyBMJ, 2010
- Does the UKCAT predict Year 1 performance in medical school?Medical Education, 2009
- Emotional intelligence in medical students: does it correlate with selection measures?Medical Education, 2009
- Social accountability and accreditation: a new frontier for educational institutionsMedical Education, 2009
- A generalizability study of the medical judgment vignettes interview to assess students' noncognitive attributes for medical schoolBMC Medical Education, 2008
- Applicants regard structured interviews as a fair method of selection: an audit of candidatesJournal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2008
- Analysis of factors that predict clinical performance in medical schoolAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2007
- Academic and personal predictors of clinical success in medical schoolAcademic Medicine, 1978