Direct recycling of electrode material from Li-ion batteries offers a cost-effective route for recycling end-of-life (EOL) cells. As recycling mandates grow and recycled material is incorporated into new cells, understanding performance of blended pristine/directly-recycled active material becomes essential. This study examines blended positive electrodes combining directly recycled EOL NMC111 with pristine NMC811 across varying ratios, demonstrating blending’s promise while revealing non-intuitive performance nuances tied to interrelated electrochemical and morphological properties. During direct recycling, EOL111’s morphology changed, as previously cracked secondary particles broke into much smaller primary particles, producing a bi-modal size distribution in the blended electrodes. While the blended electrodes’ specific capacities scaled proportionally with material ratios, the impedance, rate capability, and cycle life instead biased strongly toward the higher-performing material. Despite EOL NMC111’s much higher impedance relative to NMC811, blending 20wt% EOL NMC111 with 80wt% NMC811 had negligible impact on the cell’s rate capability and impedance. Synchrotron X-ray diffraction experiments suggest this is due to preferential utilization of the pristine NMC811 over the EOL NMC111. Conversely, EOL NMC111 exhibited superior cycle life compared to NMC811, giving the blended electrode better cycle life than electrodes containing only pristine NMC811 at 1C charging and discharging. EOL NMC111 also showed negligible growth in area specific impedance (ASI) over its lifetime, whereas NMC811’s ASI increased six-fold after 900 cycles. Finally, a techno-economic analysis establishes cost targets needed for directly recycled materials to compete economically with pristine counterparts. This work shows not only that blended electrodes are promising, but that a synergy can emerge where the blend’s performance metrics predominantly reflect the higher-performing phase.