Abstract
Cultural valuation processes have been monitored and analysed to involve co-creative and inclusive methodologies from the perspective of inclusive modalities of cultural actions, dynamics of valuation and evaluation, and the assessment of a pragmatist approach. In this chapter, we reflect on the findings collected during the research that took place between December 2021 and November 2023, experimental demonstrations where the partners analysed several main and control cases in different arenas of co-creation, presenting various politico-administrative contexts. The objective of the experimental demonstrations was to validate the results of various research tasks carried out in the UNCHARTED project, in several concrete experiments and demonstrations in collaboration with citizens, professionals, administrators, and policymakers, covering the three axes where the development of cultural values is studied, namely, cultural strategic planning, culture-led urban regeneration, and cultural information systems. The action plan proposed a pragmatist approach with a focus on co-creation approaches. The main question of methodology was therefore to trace the modalities of how cultural policies and valuation strategies can be developed in co-creation processes. In this way, the principal activities were different from those carried out in other parts of the project because the scope of the experiments and demonstrations was not to complement the research phase but rather to assess the research outcomes in concrete reallife environments. Thus, the work included meetings with public administrators, experiments in various cultural and community institutions (museums, community houses, youth centres, music centres, etc.), and public assemblies with representatives of citizens' interest groups. Furthermore, public engagement and promotion were essential elements of the activities, which also distinguished them from the approaches in the previous phases of the project. This chapter aims to provide an overall synthetic analysis to assess the impacts of the methodologies used and explore further research directions of the three broad fields/axes. The assessment is largely based on structured and targeted protocols designed to make the observations of UNCHARTED partners transparent and comparable. 1 Furthermore, the assessment also includes the discussions and external perspectives gathered during the lead team's visits to Volterra, Porto, and Barcelona and lessons learned from the UNCHARTED project's second co-creation workshop in June 2023 and the policy seminars held in December 2023 and January 2024.