Muted voices: a critical look at e‐male in organizations
Author:
- 27 July 2010
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of European Industrial Training
- Vol. 34 (6) , 539-551
Abstract
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to conceptually discuss whether and how feminine voice is muted within e-mails in organizations; the implications of which are substantial and far-reaching for human resource development (HRD) professionals as well as the HRD field as a whole. Design/methodology/approach – Utilizing the approach and arguments in muted group theory, the author conceptually applies these tenets to organizational e-mail. Findings – Current gender-preferential research concentrates on the textual polarity of male- and female-preferential language. These language differences carry over to organizational e-mail despite the lack of contextual cues within e-mail as well as the masculine nature of organizations. A critical assessment of these findings, rooted in muted group theory, reveals that women's voice is not merely marginalized (i.e. is present, but relegated to the margin), but it is mute (i.e. is not even present because it has no authentic language with which to use). Research limitations/implications – Future research should concentrate on ways in which women remain muted and strategies to “un-mute” them such that they are able to utilize a language reflective of their own experiences. Practical implications – Diversity trainers who seek to incorporate diversity into organizations must look at the deeply entrenched assumptions of a culture that embraces likeness rather than difference. Many norms and taken for granted day to day procedures, such as e-mail exchange, foster, and reinforce resistance to diversity. Originality/value – The paper urges researchers, practitioners and academics to continue to analyze critically the muteness of women in organizations.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does Diversity Pay?: Race, Gender, and the Business Case for DiversityAmerican Sociological Review, 2009
- Beyond diversity training: A social infusion for cultural inclusionHuman Resource Management, 2008
- Gazing into the crystal ball: Critical HRD as a future of research in the fieldHuman Resource Development International, 2007
- The Relationship between Gender and Topic in Gender-Preferential Language UseWritten Communication, 2004
- Gender-Linked Differences in the Style and Content of E-Mails to FriendsJournal of Language and Social Psychology, 2002
- Putting Feminist Theory to Work: Collaboration as a Means towards Organizational ChangeOrganization, 2000
- Gender Differences in the Perception and Use of E-Mail: An Extension to the Technology Acceptance Model1MIS Quarterly, 1997
- Work, gender and the futureJournal of Organizational Change Management, 1997
- The Organization of Exclusion: Institutionalization of Sex Inequality, Gendered Faculty Jobs and Gendered Knowledge in Organizational Theory and ResearchOrganization, 1994
- HIERARCHIES, JOBS, BODIES:Gender & Society, 1990