A comparison of confidence distribution approaches for rare event meta‐analysis

Authors:

Abstract
Meta‐analysis of rare event data has recently received increasing attention due to the challenging issues rare events pose to traditional meta‐analytic methods. One specific way to combine information and analyze rare event meta‐analysis data utilizes confidence distributions (CDs). While several CD methods exist, no comparisons have been made to determine which method is best suited for homogeneous or heterogeneous meta‐analyses with rare events. In this article, we review several CD methods: Fisher's classicP‐value combination method, one that combinesP‐value functions, another that combines confidence intervals, and one that combines confidence log‐likelihood functions. We compare these CD approaches, and we propose and compare variations of these methods to determine which method produces reliable results for homogeneous or heterogeneous rare event meta‐analyses. We find that for homogeneous rare event data, most CD methods perform very well. On the other hand, for heterogeneous rare event data, there is a clear split in performance between some CD methods, with some performing very poorly and others performing reasonably well.

This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit: