Comparative evaluation of six cytological grading systems in breast carcinoma
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 January 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Medknow in Journal of Cytology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 87-93
Abstract
Background: Cytological grading is a useful tool for selection of therapy and prognosis in breast carcinoma. Despite having many cytological grading systems, there is still no agreement among pathologists to accept one of them as a gold standard. Aim: This study was undertaken to evaluate six such three-tier cytological grading systems to determine which system corresponds best to histological grading done by Nottingham modification of Scarff Bloom Richardson (SBR)'s method. Materials and Methods: In a double-blind study, preoperative cytological grades obtained by six systems on fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) smears were compared by testing concordance, association and correlation with histological grade derived postoperatively by the SBR's method in 57 patients of breast carcinoma. Bivariate correlation studies and multiple linear regressions were done to assess the significance of the different cytological parameters to predict final cytological grades. Results: Robinson's system demonstrated the best correlation (ρ = 0.799; P = 0.000 and τ = 0.765; P = 0.000), maximum percent agreement (77.19%) and a substantial kappa value of agreement (κ = 0.62) with the SBR's grading system. All the six cytological grading systems correlated with histological grading strongly and positively. In multiple regression analysis, all of the cytological parameters of Robinson's system except cell size and nucleoli had significance in predicting the final cytological grade. Conclusions: Robinson's grading system is simple, more objective and reproducible, and demonstrated the best concordance with histological grading. So, Robinson's system should be used routinely for breast carcinoma aspirates.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Role of cytologic grading in prognostication of invasive breast carcinomaJournal of Cytology, 2009
- A comparative and evaluative study of cytological and histological grading system profile in malignant neoplasm of breast--an important prognostic factor.2006
- Cytopathological grading, as a predictor of histopathological grade, in ductal carcinoma (NOS) of breast, on air‐dried Diff‐Quik smearsDiagnostic Cytopathology, 2003
- Cytologic Nuclear Grade of Malignant Breast Aspirates as a Predictor of Histologic GradeActa Cytologica, 1997
- Typing and grading breast carcinoma on fine‐needle aspiration: Is this clinically useful information?Diagnostic Cytopathology, 1995
- Simplified nuclear grading of fine‐needle aspirates of breast carcinoma: Concordance with corresponding histologic nuclear grading and flow cytometric dataDiagnostic Cytopathology, 1994
- pathological prognostic factors in breast cancer. I. The value of histological grade in breast cancer: experience from a large study with long‐term follow‐upHistopathology, 1991
- Value of cytoprognostic classification in breast carcinomas.Journal of Clinical Pathology, 1986
- FINE NEEDLE ASPIRATION OF BREAST-CARCINOMA - PRELIMINARY CYTOPROGNOSTIC STUDY1980
- The pathology of invasive breast cancerA Syllabus Derived from Findings of the National Surgical Adjuvant Breast Project (Protocol No. 4)Cancer, 1975