The Complexity of ESR Signals in Tooth Enamel Fragments, A Comparison of Examples from Jebel Irhoud (Morocco) and Broken Hill (Zambia)
- 14 October 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Archaeometry
Abstract
This study presents the first comparative analysis of electron spin resonance (ESR) signal composition in fossil tooth enamel fragments from two key hominin sites: Jebel Irhoud (Morocco) and Broken Hill (Zambia). Using a simulated annealing decomposition method, we quantified the contributions of two major radical types, non‐oriented (NOCORs) and anisotropic (AICORs), to assess their impact on ESR dose estimation. NOCORs accounted for 8%–10% of the natural signal in Jebel Irhoud and 14%–15% in Broken Hill, rising significantly after gamma irradiation and leading to dose underestimation if not properly corrected. Differences in radical behavior and saturation responses between samples highlight the importance of site‐specific calibration in ESR dating. Our findings demonstrate the use of enamel fragments in ESR dating, which offer a reliable and minimally invasive alternative to conventional powder methods—particularly valuable when analyzing precious hominin fossils. The results also support the growing recognition that X‐ray irradiation in ESR dating protocols, shown in previous studies to generate no significant increase of unstable NOCORs, may provide a more effective option for equivalent dose (DE) determination without the need to correct for NOCORs.This work provides new insights into the complexity of ESR signals in teeth enamel. By addressing the impact of signal components like NOCORs, the study refines existing protocols and improves the ESR accuracy of chronologies in paleoanthropological research. Further methodological refinements will be essential to improve the accuracy of direct dating and ultimately enhance the chronologies of key early human evolution fossil specimens.Keywords
Funding Information
- Australian Research Council (ARC DP140100919, ARC DP 220100195, ARC LE200100022, ARC DP220100195)
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Datation par les méthodes ESR/U-Th combinées de sites du Pléistocène supérieur : méthodologie et application en contexte karstiqueL'Anthropologie, 2017
- ESR/U-series study of teeth recovered from the palaeoanthropological stratum of the Dali Man site (Shaanxi Province, China)Quaternary Geochronology, 2011
- Decomposition of the laboratory gamma irradiation component of angular ESR spectra of fossil tooth enamel fragmentsApplied Radiation and Isotopes, 2010
- ESR dating of tooth enamel in Mousterian layer 20, El Castillo, SpainGeoarchaeology, 2010
- Two types of CO2− radicals threaten the fundamentals of ESR dating of tooth enamelQuaternary Geochronology, 2008
- EPR of carbonate derived radicals: Applications in dosimetry, dating and detection of irradiated foodApplied Magnetic Resonance, 1998
- An EPR study of intact and powdered human tooth enamel dried at 400 CCalcified Tissue International, 1995
- ESR dating of tooth enamel: Coupled correction for U-uptake and U-series disequilibriumInternational Journal of Radiation Applications and Instrumentation. Part D. Nuclear Tracks and Radiation Measurements, 1988
- The contribution of CO3 3− and CO2 − to the ESR spectrum near g=2 of powdered human tooth enamelCalcified Tissue International, 1987
- Thermodynamical approach to the traveling salesman problem: An efficient simulation algorithmJournal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 1985