Advisory groups in realist reviews: Systematically mapping current research and recommendations for practice
Open Access
- 11 June 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Cochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods
- Vol. 2 (6) , e12073
Abstract
Introduction: Realist reviews may involve groups or panels external to the research team who provide external and independent perspectives informing the review based on their experience of the topic area. These panels or groups are termed in this study as an “advisory group.” This study aims to map current practice of advisory groups in realist reviews and provide guidance for planning and reporting. Methods: A “best‐fit” framework synthesis methodology was used by first searching for a best‐fit framework and then conducting a systematic search to identify a sample of realist reviews and rapid realist reviews (RRRs) from the most recent year, 2021. Nine databases were searched: CINAHL Complete, Cochrane, Embase, ERIC, MEDLINE, PsycInfo, Social Services Abstracts, Sociological Abstracts, and Web of Science Core Collection. Screening and data extraction was conducted by two researchers. The chosen best‐fit framework (ACTIVE framework) informed the data extraction tool. Results: One hundred and seven reviews (93 realist reviews, 14 RRRs) were identified for inclusion. Of these, 40% ( n = 37) of realist reviews and 71.5% ( n = 10) of RRRs mentioned use of an advisory group, though there was considerable variation in terminology used. Individuals in advisory groups were involved at varying stages of the review and tended to bring experience in the topic area from the perspective of (i) a lived experience, i.e., patients, carers, family members ( n = 15 realist reviews; n = 4 RRRs); (ii) professional experience, such as healthcare professionals ( n = 20 realist reviews; n = 6 RRRs); or (iii) policy or research experience in the topic area ( n = 19 realist reviews; n = 7 RRRs). Conclusions: This study proposes a definition of advisory groups, considerations for advisory group use, and suggested items for reporting. The purpose of the advisory group should be carefully considered when deciding on their use in a realist review.Keywords
This publication has 140 references indexed in Scilit:
- How do community based dementia friendly initiatives work for people with dementia and their caregivers, and why? A rapid realist reviewInternational Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 2021
- Development of a Programme Theory for Early Intervention Vocational Rehabilitation: A Realist Literature ReviewJournal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 2021
- Community-Based Interventions for the Treatment and Management of Conflict-Related Trauma in Low-Middle Income, Conflict-Affected Countries: a Realist ReviewJournal of Child & Adolescent Trauma, 2021
- An Evidence-Based Theory About PRO Use in Kidney Care: A Realist SynthesisThe Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 2021
- Patient view of the advanced practitioner (AP) role in primary care: A realist‐informed synthesisMusculoskeletal Care, 2021
- Explaining psychosocial care among unaccompanied minor refugees: a realist reviewEuropean Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2021
- Developing a Framework for Public Involvement in Mathematical and Economic Modelling: Bringing New Dynamism to Vaccination Policy RecommendationsThe Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 2021
- Lost in reviews: Looking for the involvement of stakeholders, patients, public and other non‐researcher contributors in realist reviewsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2020
- The “realist search”: A systematic scoping review of current practice and reportingResearch Synthesis Methods, 2019
- Stakeholder engagement opportunities in systematic reviews: Knowledge transfer for policy and practiceJournal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 2008