No-Take Marine Reserve Effects on Commercially Important Species and Herbivores Ten Years After Its Decree in the Mexican Caribbean
Preprint
- 27 July 2026
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
Fishing Refuge Zones (FRZs) seek to promote the recovery of exploited populations and associated ecosystems, although their effectiveness depends on various factors, such as habitat condition, the reduction of local stressors, and management implementation. We evaluated changes in the reef fish community of the Akumal FRZ, in the Mexican Caribbean, ten years after its establishment, with emphasis on commercial and herbivorous fishes. In 2025, we revisited 23 shallow and deep reef front sites surveyed in 2015 using visual censuses and benthic video transects. Fish biomass, abundance, and richness were analyzed using generalized linear mixed models; size structure using kernel density estimates; and the relationship between fish biomass and benthic condition using redundancy analysis. Commercial species showed no significant differences in biomass, richness, or size structure, but had lower abundance in 2025. In contrast, herbivores showed higher biomass and a shift toward a larger modal size, although with lower abundance and richness. These changes occurred on a reef with lower coral cover in 2025 and a predominance of brown algae in both periods. The results show a partial and functionally heterogeneous response, in a context of persistent degradation and limitations in management implementation and continuity.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2026-07-27, Preprints
- Published version: Diversity, 18 (9), 546.
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating MPA success for Caribbean reef fish: the role of design, habitat, and managementCoral Reefs, 2026
- Marine protected areas stage of establishment and level of protection are good predictors of their conservation outcomesCell Reports Sustainability, 2025
- Coral reef erosion: In situ measurement on different dead coral substrates on a Caribbean reefLimnology and Oceanography, 2022
- The unprecedented loss of Florida's reef‐building corals and the emergence of a novel coral‐reef assemblageEcology, 2019
- Rapid tourism growth and declining coral reefs in Akumal, MexicoMarine Biology, 2015
- Water quality assessment in the Mexican Caribbean: Impacts on the coastal ecosystemContinental Shelf Research, 2015
- Importance of live coral habitat for reef fishesReviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries, 2013
- The importance of structural complexity in coral reef ecosystemsCoral Reefs, 2012
- Influence of habitat degradation on fish replenishmentCoral Reefs, 2010
- Two-Sample Test Statistics for Measuring Discrepancies Between Two Multivariate Probability Density Functions Using Kernel-Based Density EstimatesJournal of Multivariate Analysis, 1994