Evaluating clinical practice guidelines developed for the management of thyroid nodules and thyroid cancers and assessing the reliability and validity of the AGREE instrument
- 11 January 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice
- Vol. 17 (4) , 729-736
Abstract
Objectives We assessed the quality of a sample of clinical guidelines for thyroid nodules and thyroid cancers, using the Appraisal of Guidelines Research and Evaluation (AGREE) instrument. We also evaluated the reliability and validity of the AGREE instrument and summarized the key recommendations of the appraised guidelines. Methods Twenty-six clinical researchers and endocrinologists who had been trained in the principles of developing clinical guidelines and using the AGREE instrument participated in the study and appraised the guidelines. Clinical guidelines selected via a systematic search were assessed, each by eight participants. We compared the AGREE domain scores of the guidelines, and compared the participants' scores before and after group discussions. We used Cronbach's alpha, and intraclass correlation coefficients to assess the reliability, and the Spearman's rho to assess the correlation between the overall assessment and other variables. Results Seven guidelines were included in the study. 'Scope and purpose' and 'clarity and presentation' achieved the highest domain scores. 'Applicability' received the lowest domain scores and reliability coefficients. 'Rigor of development' and 'clarity and presentation' obtained the highest correlations with overall assessment scores. There was a significant relationship between the overall assessment score and the numbers of algorithms, tables and figures in the guidelines. Conclusions We identified three clinical guidelines that obtained high overall assessment scores and were recommended for use in practice. Our findings have important implications for those developing clinical guidelines, especially as clarity and presentation significantly influenced the participants' assessment of the guidelines. The developers should ensure that the recommendations are presented clearly and unambiguously, and flowcharts, algorithms and other tools are developed to help the users in applying the recommendations into practice. The optimal number of appraisers for each guideline is four. Further work is needed to improve the 'applicability' domain of the AGREE.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Adapting valid clinical guidelines for use in primary care in low and middle income countriesPrimary Care Respiratory Journal, 2008
- Management Guidelines for Patients with Thyroid Nodules and Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: The American Thyroid Association Guidelines TaskforceThyroid®, 2006
- Guideline Quality and Guideline Content: Are They Related?Clinical Chemistry, 2006
- The Thyroid NoduleNew England Journal of Medicine, 2004
- Development and validation of an international appraisal instrument for assessing the quality of clinical practice guidelines: the AGREE projectQuality and Safety in Health Care, 2003
- Development and application of a generic methodology to assess the quality of clinical guidelinesInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care, 1999
- The Relation between Systematic Reviews and Practice GuidelinesAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1997
- Thyroid Incidentalomas: Management Approaches to Nonpalpable Nodules Discovered Incidentally on Thyroid ImagingAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1997
- THE SPECTRUM OF THYROID DISEASE IN A COMMUNITY: THE WHICKHAM SURVEYClinical Endocrinology, 1977
- The Significance of Nontoxic Thyroid NodulesAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1968