Abstract
Background: The purpose of this study was to objectively compare methodological approaches that might be utilized in designing an antimicrobial resistance (AMR) surveillance program in beef feedlot cattle. Specifically, four separate comparisons were made to investigate their potential impact on estimates for prevalence of AMR. These included investigating potential differences between 2 different susceptibility testing methods (broth microdilution and disc diffusion), between 2 different target bacteria (non-type-specificE.coli[NTSEC] andMannheimia haemolytica), between 2 strategies for sampling feces (individual samples collected per rectum and pooled samples collected from the pen floor), and between 2 strategies for determining which cattle to sample (cattle that were culture-positive forMannheimia haemolyticaand those that were culture-negative).Results: Comparing two susceptibility testing methods demonstrated differences in the likelihood of detecting resistance between automated disk diffusion (BioMIC®) and broth microdilution (Sensititre®) for bothE.coliandM. haemolytica. Differences were also detected when comparing resistance between two bacterial organisms within the same cattle; there was a higher likelihood of detecting resistance inE.colithan inM. haemolytica. Differences in resistance prevalence were not detected when using individual animal or composite pen sampling strategies. No differences in resistance prevalences were detected inE.colirecovered from cattle that were culture-positive forM. haemolyticacompared to those that were culture-negative, suggesting that sampling strategies which targeted recovery ofE.colifromM. haemolytica-positive cattle would not provide biased results.Conclusions: We found that for general purposes, the susceptibility test selected for AMR surveillance must be carefully chosen considering the purpose of the surveillance since the ability to detect resistance appears to vary between these tests depending upon the population where they are applied. Continued surveillance of AMR inM. haemolyticarecovered by nasopharyngeal swab is recommended if monitoring an animal health pathogen is an objective of the surveillance program as results of surveillance using fecalE.colicannot be extrapolated to this important respiratory pathogen. If surveillance ofE.coliwas pursued in the same population, study populations could target animals that were culture-positive forM. haemolyticawithout biasing estimates for AMR inE.coli. Composite pen-floor sampling or sampling of individuals per-rectum could possibly be used interchangeably for monitoring resistance inE.coli.

This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit: