Double normalization: When procedural law is made digital
Open Access
- 1 June 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Onati International Institute for the Sociology of Law in Oñati Socio-Legal Series
- Vol. 12 (3) , 656-690
Abstract
The comparison of three e-justice platforms (EJP) leads to the identification of a common dynamic – called double normalization – which makes EJP development an institutional and constitutional issue, not just a functional one. The case study analysis of Trial on Line in Italy, e-Curia (Court of Justice of the European Union) and Kwaliteit en Innovatie rechtspraak in the Netherlands shows how EJPs, establishing the working environment for judges, lawyers, and clerks, create more powerful constraints than those provided by the law. The normalization carried out by legal standards to make judicial procedures predictable and homogeneous and grant equal treatment is supplemented by the digital working environment. Hence technology provides an additional layer of normalization, steering the behaviour of judges in predetermined directions and inhibiting other action pathways. The process challenges the right of the judge to interpret procedural law and require appropriate judicial governance mechanisms to safeguard fair trial.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Designing and Implementing e-Justice Systems: Some Lessons Learned from EU and Canadian ExamplesLaws, 2014
- Searching for Maximum Feasible Simplicity: The Case of e-Curia at the Court of Justice of the European Union2013
- Pushing at the Edge of Maximum Manageable Complexity: The Case of ‘Trial Online’ in Italy2013
- How the Law Can Make It Simple: Easing the Circulation of Agency in e-Justice2013
- The Circulation of Agency in Judicial Proceedings: Designing for Interoperability and Complexity2013
- Challenges in enterprise resource planning implementation: state‐of‐the‐artBusiness Process Management Journal, 2010
- Organizational culture and leadership in ERP implementationDecision Support Systems, 2008
- Legal and Technological NormativityTechné: Research in Philosophy and Technology, 2008
- The dynamics of contextual forces of ERP implementationThe Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 2005
- Critical Issues Affecting an ERP ImplementationInformation Systems Management, 1999