Computation, External Factors, and Cognitive Explanations
Author:
- 14 February 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Philosophical Psychology
- Vol. 20 (1) , 65-80
Abstract
Computational properties, it is standardly assumed, are to be sharply distinguished from semantic properties. Specifically, while it is standardly assumed that the semantic properties of a cognitive system are externally or non-individualistically individuated, computational properties are supposed to be individualistic and internal. Yet some philosophers (e.g., Tyler Burge) argue that content impacts computation, and further, that environmental factors impact computation. Oron Shagrir has recently argued for these theses in a novel way, and gave them novel interpretations. In this paper I present a conception of computation in cognitive science that takes Shagrir's conception as its starting point, but further develops it in various directions and strengthens it. I argue that the explanatory role of computational properties emerges from the idea that syntactical properties and the relevant external factors presented by cognitive systems compose wide computational properties. I also elaborate upon the notion of content that is in play, and argue that it is contents of the kind that are ascribed by transparent interpretations of content ascriptions that impact computation. This fact enables the thesis that external factors impact computation to rebuff the challenge which concerns the claim that psychology must be individualistic.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Externalism, the environment, and thought-tokensErkenntnis, 2005
- Content, Computation and ExternalismMind, 2001
- Computation and ContentPhilosophical Review, 1995
- Wide ComputationalismMind, 1994
- A Modal Argument for Narrow ContentThe Journal of Philosophy, 1991
- Defence of a Reasonable IndividualismMind, 1991
- Individualism and Perceptual ContentMind, 1991
- Individualism and PsychologyPhilosophical Review, 1986
- Methodological solipsism considered as a research strategy in cognitive psychologyBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1980
- Autonomous Psychology and the Belief-Desire ThesisThe Monist, 1978