Semimechanical side-to-side stapled anastomosis is thought to reduce frequency of leaks and strictures when using whole stomach. Scarce data are available when using gastric tubulisation. Two matched groups of patients, operated between 2005 and 2008, were retrieved receiving a cervical oesophagogastrostomy on gastric tubulisation: 92 semimechanical anastomoses (SMA), 41 hand-sewn anastomoses (HSA). EORTC QLC-30 and OES-18 questionnaires were used to score anastomosis related symptoms. A difference of 10 points or 10% was considered clinically significant. Overall incidence of anastomotic leaks was 4.5%. Leakage rate in SMA was 2.17% vs 4.88% in HSA (P = 0.587). Dilatation occurred in 30% of SMA and 61% of HSA (P < 0.001), 15% and 49% respectively needing ≥3 dilatations (P < 0.001). Both groups demonstrated an initial increase of dysphagia score, being steeper for patients with HSA (mean score 31 vs 26). At 3 months, dysphagia subscales revealed higher mean scores for solids (HSA 38 and SMA 31) than for semisolids (HSA 30 and SMA 20) and for liquids (HSA 25 and SMA 26). Dichotomized results in symptomatic/asymptomatic showed a significantly higher percentage of HSA patients (33%) being symptomatic for difficulties swallowing solids compared to SMA patients (22%). HSA patients also had a significantly higher score for swallowing saliva (30 vs 20). After 3 months, no more significant differences were seen, except for reflux at 1 year being 27 % in HSA vs 16% for SMA. Patients in both groups gave a similar global HRQL score at all timepoints. Semimechanical anastomosis results in better dysphagia scores for solids and semisolids and reduces significantly the need for dilatations, in particular repeat dilatations. The negative effect of dysphagia in the HSA group fades out over time, probably due to the treatment, i.e. dilatations. Semimechanical anastomosis can be safely used after gastric tubulisation thus allowing resection of the lesser curvature, an important oncologic principle for distal half tumours. All authors have declared no conflicts of interest.