The Wisdom of Negativity: Embracing Public Concerns About Emerging Technologies
Open Access
- 25 January 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in NanoEthics
- Vol. 19 (1) , 1-10
Abstract
There can be a temptation to dismiss moral pushback against novel science and technology, particularly commonplace labels for nanotechnology and synthetic biology like “playing God” or “messing with nature". One of the reasons for this is an implicit association between tragic themes and a lack of constructive benefit. Therefore, this paper uses concepts from art and cinema to offer a new perspective on public "fears": ecstatic reframing. By treating negative narratives not as roadblocks to progress, but portals into latent dreams, this novel method reframes such views as housing a positive vision. However, while this offers a new approach regarding public talk of emerging science and technology, lay ethics is ultimately insufficient to deal with the underlying problems that stimulate their tragic tone. This paper uses a classic concept from anthropology--rites of passage--to argue that public unease is fundamentally cultural: modernity's lack of a collectively agreed upon worldview and primordial ritual structure for stewarding change. This "cultural deficit" may lie at the core of tragic narratives regarding emerging science and technology.Keywords
Funding Information
- Western Sydney University
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Playing God: Symbolic Arguments Against TechnologyNanoEthics, 2022
- Scientifically framed gene drive communication perceived as credible but riskierPeople and Nature, 2021
- Playing God and tampering with nature: popular labels for real concerns in synthetic biologyTransgenic Research, 2021
- The six scenario archetypes framework: A systematic investigation of science fiction films set in the futureFutures, 2020
- Alternative Futures at the Manoa School2019
- The Ethics and Ontology of Synthetic Biology: a Neo-Aristotelian PerspectiveNanoEthics, 2019
- Synthetic Biology2016
- The Narratology of Lay EthicsNanoEthics, 2010
- Narratives of Mastery and Resistance: Lay Ethics of NanotechnologyNanoEthics, 2010
- Playing God? Synthetic biology as a theological and ethical challengeSystems and Synthetic Biology, 2009