Debate: Is ACE screening doing more harm than good? A consideration of screening versus child health surveillance
Author:
Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Child and Adolescent Mental Health
- Vol. 31 (4) , 351-353
Abstract
The ACEs questionnaire has been used in population epidemiology for decades and is now recommended, by some authors, for screening purposes. However, screening programmes bring both harms and benefits and are different from population epidemiology and clinical enquiry. In this paper, I use a modern modification of Wilson and Jungner's screening programme criteria to consider whether a screening programme for ACEs would be advisable. I conclude that a screening programme for ACEs would not be appropriate and might be harmful. However, routine child health surveillance, with close collaboration across agencies including health, education and social work, is essential to ensure that ACEs, and potential harms arising from ACEs, are avoided wherever possible. A composite case example from Scotland, a country with a well‐developed child health surveillance system, is provided to illustrate how such a system can support children who have experienced ACEs and their families.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Stability of childhood maltreatment self-reports: a systematic review and meta-analysisNature Mental Health, 2026
- Infant mental health services for birth and foster families of maltreated pre-school children in foster care (BeST?): a cluster-randomized phase 3 clinical effectiveness trialNature Medicine, 2025
- The Importance of Screening for Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) in all Medical EncountersAJPM Focus, 2023
- The Adverse Childhood Experiences – International Questionnaire (ACE-IQ) in community samples around the world: A systematic review (part I)Child Abuse & Neglect, 2022
- Mortality in Persons With Autism Spectrum Disorder or Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity DisorderJAMA Pediatrics, 2022
- Trajectories of resilience and dysfunction following potential trauma: A review and statistical evaluationClinical Psychology Review, 2018
- Consolidated principles for screening based on a systematic review and consensus processCanadian Medical Association Journal, 2018
- Maltreatment‐associated neurodevelopmental disorders: a co‐twin control analysisJournal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 2017
- Adult resilience among maltreated children: A prospective investigation of main effect and mediating modelsChildren and Youth Services Review, 2013
- Maximising benefit and minimising harm of screeningBMJ, 2008