A community of practice around article peer review: A collaborative autoethnography
Open Access
- 3 December 2025
- journal article
- Published by Open Access Publishing Association in Journal of University Teaching and Learning Practice
- Vol. 22 (7)
Abstract
Learning from peer reviewer practice is one example of person-centred inquiry relevant to the broad practice of journal publishing. This curriculum inquiry adopts a practice-led inquiry (Gray, 1996) alongside a collaborative autoethnographic approach (CAE) utilising the conversations between two peer reviewers both involved in a journal driven peer review professional learning community of practice. We were interested in exploring our learnings from a peer-review professional learning program and as such our CAE methodology framed our four final research questions which were concerned with the successes and challenges of the professional learning program; the successes and challenges of a community of practice (CoP) as a vehicle for the program; the effectiveness of the program’s curriculum and the way the discussion on curriculum impacted our broader learnings. The conversations reveal insights about peer review professional learning as well as broader insights regarding the value of community of practice (CoP) as a vehicle for professional learning. Development of relational trust between professionals is a key factor in facilitating academic professional learning and this has implications for the wider ways of working with fellow academics.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Group-based journal review: opportunities for researcher development and enjoymentInternational Journal for Academic Development, 2024
- Autoethnography as an ethically contested terrain: some thinking points for considerationQualitative Research in Psychology, 2024
- Reflective Practice Within Elite Consultancy: Diary Extracts and Further Discussion on a Personal and Elusive ProcessThe Sport Psychologist, 2012
- Making the Business School More ‘Critical’: Reflexive Critique Based on Phronesis as a Foundation for ImpactBritish Journal of Management, 2010
- The concept of critical reflection: promises and contradictionsEuropean Journal of Social Work, 2009
- ‘Learning supervision’: trial by fireInnovations in Education and Teaching International, 2009
- Communities of Practice: The Organizational Frontier2006
- The development of research supervision: “Turning the light on a private space”International Journal for Academic Development, 2005
- Loop inputELT Journal, 2003
- Transforming Teaching Practice: Becoming the critically reflective teacherReflective Practice, 2000