Religion, hate speech and non-domination
- 9 March 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Ethnicities
- Vol. 17 (2) , 259-274
Abstract
In this paper, I argue that one way of explaining what is wrong with hate speech is by critically assessing what kind of freedom free speech involves and, relatedly, what kind of freedom hate speech undermines. More specifically, I argue that the main arguments for freedom of speech (e.g. from truth, autonomy and democracy) rely on a ‘positive’ conception of freedom intended as autonomy and self-mastery or as collective self-government, and can only partially help us to understand what is wrong with hate speech. In order to fully grasp the wrongness of hate speech and to justify hate speech legislation, I claim, we need to rely instead on the republican idea of freedom as ‘non-domination’. I conclude that the hate speech used by religious citizens, even though it is a manifestation of their religious freedom, should be subject to the same restrictions that apply to other citizens’ hate speech, because republicans should be concerned with the undominated (i.e. robustly secured) religious freedom of all religious citizens and, more generally, with the undominated freedoms of all citizens, including those who are victims of religious hate speech.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hate Speech Law2015
- On the Origins of Jewish Self-Hatred2012
- On the People's Terms2012
- The Harm in Hate Speech2012
- Does Freedom of Speech Include Hate Speech?Res Publica, 2011
- Mill's liberal principles and freedom of expression2009
- Critical Republicanism2008
- The Racial and Religious Hatred Act 2006: a Millian responseCritical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 2008
- IS THERE A RIGHT TO PORNOGRAPHY?†Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 1981
- The First Amendment Is an AbsoluteThe Supreme Court Review, 1961