Study on the Factors Affecting the Drainage Efficiency of New Integrated Irrigation and Drainage Networks and Network Optimization Based on Annual Cost System
Open Access
Abstract
With the frequent occurrence of extreme weather events worldwide, the compound frequency of drought and flood events has significantly increased, imposing multidimensional pressures on agricultural water resource management. Agricultural water consumption accounts for approximately 70%, with severe waste, as a large amount of water is lost during transmission and distribution. Faced with increasingly severe and frequent extreme weather, traditional drainage systems may become unsustainable. Identifying the factors influencing drainage time is crucial for efficient drainage. The MIKE URBAN model has significant potential in farmland waterlogging simulation and drainage network optimization. This study validated the model’s accuracy based on infiltration well overflow capacity experiments, with Average Relative Error (ARE) values of 2.29%, 6.52%, 4.41%, 3.17%, 4.37%, and 5.69%, demonstrating good simulation accuracy. The MIKE URBAN model was used to simulate drainage networks, explore factors affecting drainage time, establish an annual cost system for the drainage network, and optimize the network using a genetic algorithm with the objective of minimizing annual costs. Research findings: There is a clear negative correlation between the maximum inflow of infiltration wells and drainage time. As inflow increases, drainage becomes faster, but beyond 0.0075 m3/s (27 m3/h), the efficiency gains level off. This indicates that selecting infiltration wells with at least a 20% opening ratio is essential. Similarly, increasing the collector’s diameter enhances drainage efficiency significantly, though the effect follows a diminishing return pattern. While smaller lateral spacing improves local water collection, it may lead to flow congestion if the collector is undersized; conversely, larger spacing increases drainage paths and delays, even if the collector is large. An optimal spacing range of 100–150 m is suggested alongside the collector diameter. Lateral diameter also affects performance: increasing it reduces drainage time, but the benefit plateaus around 200 mm, making further enlargement cost-ineffective. The genetic algorithm helped to optimize the drainage network design. Utilizing the genetic algorithm, the drainage network was optimized in just 15 iterations. The fitness function value rapidly decreased from 351,000 CNY to 55,000 CNY and then stabilized, reducing the annual cost from 59,640.67 CNY to 45,337.86 CNY—a 24% savings—highlighting the approach’s effectiveness in designing efficient and economical farmland drainage systems. This study has shown that the simulation-based optimization of drainage networks provides a more rational and cost-effective approach to planning drainage infrastructure.Keywords
Funding Information
- Science and Technology Major Project of the Ministry of Water Resources of China (SKS-2022050, 2023YFD1900802-01, 23CXNA0025)
- National Key Research and Development Program of China (SKS-2022050, 2023YFD1900802-01, 23CXNA0025)
- The Gansu Province Science and Technology Program—East–West Cooperation Special Project (SKS-2022050, 2023YFD1900802-01, 23CXNA0025)
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hydrogeochemical characteristics and evolution of formation water in the continental sedimentary basin: A case study in the Qaidam Basin, ChinaScience of The Total Environment, 2024
- Evaluation of comprehensive benefits of sponge cities using meta-analysis in different geographical environments in ChinaScience of The Total Environment, 2022
- Irrigation Pipe Network Planning at Tertiary Level: An Indian Case StudyKSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 2019
- Development of Optimal Pipe Size Design Tool for Irrigation Systems and its Application to Saemangeum Reclamation AreaIrrigation and Drainage, 2016
- Improved genetic algorithm optimization of water distribution system design by incorporating domain knowledgeEnvironmental Modelling & Software, 2015
- Multiobjective Optimization for Least Cost Design and Resiliency of Water Distribution SystemsJournal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2014
- Management of agricultural drainage systems in the Czech RepublicIrrigation and Drainage, 2007
- Optimization of irrigation water distribution networks, layout includedAgricultural Water Management, 2007
- Irrigation Pipe Network Design Using Geographic Information System2000
- An evolutionary approach for finding optimal trees in undirected networksEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2000