Shifts in positive and negative affect (i.e., changes between two points in time) activate motivational and behavioural processes and have shown distinct patterns in predicting work engagement and performance over and above affect from one point in time. However, challenges remain in how affective shifts relate to other indicators of psychological functioning and how interindividual differences influence that relation. To address those gaps, we employed a daily diary study to examine how affective shifts (from the evening to the next morning) interact to predict subjective vitality (next morning), and whether positive stress beliefs (i.e., implicit beliefs that stress has enhancing consequences for one’s well-being) moderate their interaction. Whereas we could not find a significant two-way interaction effect, results from our three-way interaction model revealed that positive stress beliefs moderated how upshifts in negative affect predict subjective vitality. Specifically, upshifts in positive affect were stronger related to subjective vitality when they were coupled with upshifts in negative affect in cases of high positive stress beliefs. For low positive stress beliefs, we could not find interaction effects in affective shifts predicting subjective vitality. We discuss the contributions of our findings to stress and affective shift literature along with practical implications.